Tokyo FinTech
Published in

Tokyo FinTech

Brokerage or Advertising of Financial Products?

The Financial Services Commission (FSC) and Financial Supervisory Service (FSS) announced on September 7 that FinTech & BigTech companies’ recommendations of financial products, such as insurance or investment products, through their platforms would be regarded as brokerage rather than advertising. As brokerage by unregistered business entities is prohibited, big-tech and fintech companies need to modify or halt such services until they resolve the regulatory requirements.

The market reaction was swift, with both Naver and Kakao experiencing 15–20% drawdowns in the Seoul market, and Coupang, which went public on the NYSE earlier this year and had just about started to recover from a prolonged decline since the IPO, giving back a little less than 10%.

Graphs sourced from Yahoo! Finance

The FSC has performed a detailed review to determine if major online financial platform services comply with the Financial Consumer Protection Act. The results were shared with the service providers, and are also publicly available in Korean.

The Financial Consumer Protection Act included a grace period of six months after its enactment on March 25 this year, so the FSC action can be seen as closing any gaps prior to September 24.

In their press release, the FSC stressed that it is necessary to prevent damage to consumers due to incomplete sales, increase in brokerage fees, and bias in online algorithms due to non-qualified and irresponsible persons for the sale of financial products.

If the purpose of online financial platform service is to sell, not to provide information, it can be generally regarded as a brokerage. A clear indication here is whether the payment of commissions according to sales performance occurs, rather than just an advertisement placement fee.

Even though the online financial platform is not a financial product seller, the FSC considered whether there is a possibility that consumers may mistake the contract to executed with the platform. Thus, although consumer trust in the platform is one of the important factors in contract decision-making, it is necessary to prevent a situation in which the platform is not liable.

Overall, the market reaction seems overdone given the relatively small revenue pool impacted, but has certainly be influenced by the current regulatory tightening in China. However, in our view this is just a step to bring the platforms into compliance with already enacted law, not the first step in attempting to break up these players. Quite to the contrary, the tech platforms play a decisive role in Korea’s growth strategy, also referred to as the “K-New Deal”.

This article is part of our Tokyo FinTech Publication, please follow us to read more from our writers, like hundreds of readers do every day. Please also register for our short weekly digest, published every Saturday, at the link below.

Should you live in Tokyo, or just pass through, please also join our Tokyo FinTech Meetup. In any case, our YouTube channel, LinkedIn page, Facebook page and our Instagram account are there for you as well.




一般社団法人 (General Incorporated Association) Tokyo FinTech is registered as a non-profit organization in Japan, promoting the domestic ecosystem through innovation

Recommended from Medium

Why China’s New 3 Child Policy Wouldn’t Help in its Quest to be a World Power

Surveillance, Privacy and Abuse of Power: Is the Coronavirus Pandemic and Opportunity for…

The oligarchs will definitely strike back

UK Government has painted themselves into a corner with Coronavirus Lockdown!

Distraught Hong Kong villagers battle to save their homes

fire in bilaspur railway store: Bilaspur Massive fire in railway store, aluminum cables worth…

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Norbert Gehrke

Norbert Gehrke

Passionate about strategy & innovation across Asia. At home in Japan. Connector of people & ideas.

More from Medium

Working at the Speed of Thought: Investing in Wispr AI

Why we invested in DebtStream

Bridging Privacy Tech Gaps & Fueling the Future of Privacy Tech: Investors

Frontline’s 2021 in Review