The Filter Theory of the Mind-Brain Connection

Gerald R. Baron
Top-Down or Bottom-Up?
13 min readAug 7, 2020

--

The age-old question of the mind-brain connection may find its answer in the age-old idea of the “mother-sea” of consciousness and the brain as a filter. Cloud computing and smartphones may help us understand this.

Pawel Nolbert on unsplash. William James called it the “mother-sea,” Carl Jung and Wolfgang Pauli called it “unus mundus.” What is there about the idea of universal consciousness that many in science and philosophy today are finding so interesting?

How does the mind relate to the brain? Physicalists are bottom-up thinkers on this question believing that all there is has evolved from the very beginnings of our universe. The fact that we have brains is a result of blind and random forces including the laws of physics and Darwinian evolution defined as the outcome of random mutation and natural selection. Our conscious thoughts or subjective experiences either are an illusion or emerge in a physical process happening in our brains in a way that is not yet understood. Because we live in a clockwork universe with unchangeable physical laws that are the total cause of everything that happens, the thoughts you have as you read this have been fully predetermined. There is no free will. Should you decide you’ve had enough of this post, that decision was set in stone as well. Bottom-up physicalist thinking is understood as the consensus view of mainstream science and is the one adopted and defended by the drivers of our culture including education, journalism and entertainment.

Top-down thinkers do not doubt the reality of consciousness nor subjective experience. Many versions…

--

--

Top-Down or Bottom-Up?
Top-Down or Bottom-Up?

Published in Top-Down or Bottom-Up?

Is consciousness produced by the physical material of the brain or is it “something more?” The issue is a major dividing line between physicalists and anti-physicalists with big implications for our culture and values.

Gerald R. Baron
Gerald R. Baron

Written by Gerald R. Baron

Dawdling at the intersection of faith, science, philosophy and theology. Author of It Was My Turn, a Vietnam story.