Transgender rights: How supportive is your country?
Spain is the country most supportive of transgender rights, according to a poll published in December 2016. The survey was conducted as a collaboration between BuzzFeed News, polling firm Ipsos and the UCLA Law School’s Williams Institute. Buzzfeed has called the survey the “first of its kind”.
Participants from 23 countries were asked their opinion on a variety of transgender issues ranging from protection against discrimination to more specific rights such as marriage and adoption. Countries were ranked with an overall score out of 100 points.
Those who were younger and those with higher levels of income or education were generally more supportive of trans people. Women also showed more support for transgender rights than men.
Spain topped the list with a score of 81, ahead of Sweden (77) and Argentina (76), despite the fact that only 23% of Spanish people said they even knew a transgender person (9th place).
Image: BuzzFeed News/Ipsos/UCLA Law School’s Williams Institute
Six countries fell below the 60 points mark, while Russia was the only country to score below 50 points overall.
It depends how you define rights
The Williams Institute optimistically reported that “in all 23 countries, majorities of survey respondents supported important transgender rights”, though the level of support from each country depended greatly on which right, in particular, was being addressed.
In all 23 countries, a majority of those surveyed said they supported the right to change identity documents, although most still felt some kind regulation from medical professionals and governments was necessary. In 21 countries, a majority said they supported policies banning discrimination against transgender people. Support dwindled, however, when asking about specific rights such as the right to marry (16 countries), to adopt (14 countries) or to access the public restroom of one’s gender identity (15 countries).
In the United States, where access to public restrooms has become the focal point of transgender rights, only 47% of those surveyed said they thought transgender people should have the right to use the restroom of the sex the identify with.
Image: BuzzFeed News/Ipsos/UCLA Law School’s Williams Institute
Actually knowing a trans person can have a huge impact
Actually knowing a transgender person makes a big difference. The Williams Institute explains that: “Having transgender friends and family members has a strong effect on support for transgender rights. Those who report having such relationships are significantly more supportive of transgender rights than those who report not having such relationships.”
The survey found that those who knew a transgender person were 24.6% more likely to support transgender rights.
Those findings echo a study published in Science Magazine last year which showed that a 10-minute conversation about transgender rights can not only influence people’s opinions, but can also make them less likely to believe negative portrayals of trans people in the future.
The difficulty remains that most people do not know anyone who is transgender. While the community is growing rapidly, the number of people who say they know a trans person stands at 26%. That number is actually down slightly from a Pew Survey conducted in 2016.
Worldwide, not a single country had a majority of people who said they knew a trans person. Brazil scored highest, with 50%.
Image: BuzzFeed News/Ipsos/UCLA Law School’s Williams Institute
The survey was conducted using an international sample of over 17,000 participants from 23 countries. Participants answered questions between July and August of 2016.
Originally published at weforum.org.
