The Top 3 Pizza Places in Gainesville, Georgia

North Metro Eateries
Travel Georgia
Published in
2 min readMay 31, 2022

As avid pizza lovers, we are always down for a slice.

Pizza chef making pizza

All three of these pizza places are amazing with immaculate vibes, however each has a different style of pizza. So naturally we had to rank them.

  1. Atlas Pizza
Supreme calzone from Atlas Pizza

The absolute GOAT for pizza! Atlas features hand tossed thick crust which is the perfect vessel for transporting the mounds of toppings. From the top tier crust that is covered in garlic butter to the freshest toppings ever, every bit of this pizza leaves you oohing and ah-ing. The vibe is really laid back and casual with some outdoor and indoor seating options. We love to come here for the salad and pizza because the prices are great and everything is always A+.

2. Peyton’s Pie Co

Peytons Classic from Peytons Pie Co

While Peyton’s Pie Co isn’t officially in Gainesville yet, we are so excited for it to come. The current location in Flowery Branch is next door for a taproom which makes for a fun night with friends. This pizza is Neapolitan style with an aged crust. The rotating wood fired grill creates a beautifully made pizza with touches of char. The natural ingredients and curated toppings pair well with a glass of wine. Their second location coming to Gainesville will be located in the Magnolia Market, so you can enjoy a glass of wine from Cork It with a pizza from Peyton’s Pie Co.

3. Sliced Gainesville

Margherita Pizza from Sliced

Sliced is your classic New York style pizza with your choice of toppings. With 5 locations, they are taking over North Georgia as your go to mom and pop pizza place. Each location is unique from the last yet they all have the same welcoming feel when you walk in. The Oakwood location is our go to because they have a dog friendly patio. The classic pizza makes it great for getting take out! The elevated flavors and quality make Sliced a hit with parties.

--

--

North Metro Eateries
Travel Georgia

Food bloggers writing all about North Georgia and Metro Atlanta. Follow us on Instagram @NorthMetroEateries