The Dark Legacy of the “Hangman”: Unveiling the Horrifying Crimes of Gerard John Schaefer Jr.

Eve S Evans
True Crime Hub
Published in
4 min readSep 8, 2023

--

In the annals of crime, there are few stories as disturbing and chilling as that of Gerard John Schaefer Jr., a former sheriff’s deputy turned suspected serial killer. Operating in the 1970s in the sun-soaked state of Florida, Schaefer’s heinous acts of sadism and murder earned him the notorious monikers of the “Hangman” and the “Killer Cop.” Today, we delve into the dark abyss of Schaefer’s twisted mind and recount the horrors he inflicted upon his victims.

Described by prosecutor Robert Stone as “the most sexually deviant person” he had ever encountered, Schaefer’s depravity knew no bounds. Born in 1946, he initially seemed an unlikely candidate for a life of violence. However, beneath his unassuming facade lurked a predator driven by sinister desires.

As a sheriff’s deputy in Martin County, Florida, Schaefer wielded a badge that concealed his true nature. His position allowed him to exploit the trust placed in law enforcement officers, enabling him to prey on vulnerable women undetected. It is believed that Schaefer’s reign of terror began as early as 1969.

What set Schaefer apart from other killers was his macabre ritual. He would bind his victims, often young women, to trees with a hangman’s noose around their necks. This twisted act served as a harbinger of the torment and suffering that awaited them. Schaefer’s victims would endure unimaginable horrors, subjected to brutal acts of torture before…

--

--

Eve S Evans
True Crime Hub

Content writer transfixed by anything paranormal and unexplained. Focuses on Ghosts, Paranormal and True Crime. Published author & podcaster.