MTV’s The Challenge Spotlight: Evelyn Smith

The best female challenger of all-time.

Evelyn Smith / Photos by The Challenge Wiki & Stop Being Polite

Evelyn Smith is the best female competitor MTV’s The Challenge has ever seen. She had a 5 year run on the show from 2006–2011 and was one of the main characters in each season she was on besides her first season of Fresh Meat. On Fresh Meat she was the first partnership eliminated but that was more due to her partner than her. I’m going to deep dive into her entire career and write about what could have happened if she never retired after winning Rivals in 2011.

Fast Facts

Original Show: The Challenge: Fresh Meat

Debut: Fresh Meat

Seasons: 7

• Fresh Meat
• The Inferno III (1st)
• The Gauntlet III (2nd)
• The Island (1st)
• The Ruins
• Fresh Meat II
• Rivals (1st)

Daily Wins: 25

Eliminations Record: 6–3

Evelyn on Fresh Meat II / Photo by Pinterest

Season by Season Synopsis