The Traitors 4 Fantasy Cast
The best show on TV just keeps getting better and better.
The Traitors on Peacock is the best reality tv competition show on TV right now. It is beating out shows like The Challenge and Big Brother each year. Season 3 just finished airing and was fantastic even if it was a little too friendly at the end. I think Gabby and Dylan were fantastic especially towards the end. Here is my fantasy cast for a potential season 4 of the hit show.
The Traitors
Jordan Wiseley
Original Show - The Real World: Portland
Also Seen On:
- The Challenge
Jordan is a 5-time Champion of The Challenge. He is a big personality who is not afraid to share how he feels about people. He most recently won The Challenge: Battle of the Era’s in 2024 which was the shows 40th season. Jordan has been the same big personality all the way back to his days on The Real World in 2013. I’d love to see how he’d play as a traitor. I chose traitor for him because as a faithful I could see him playing a huge role and getting eliminated early. A faithful would make him think.
Alyssa Edwards
Original Show - RuPaul’s Drag Race 5
Alyssa is the face of RuPaul’s Drag Race. His real name is Justin Johnson and he was on season 1 of “The Goat” on Amazon. He knows how to bring drama but also bring competition. To be honest I think Alyssa/Justin could be the first member of RuPaul’s Drag Race to win The Traitors.
Charity Lawson
Original Show - The Bachelorette 20
- Charity was originally on The Bachelor 27 but was the lead on The Bachelorette 20.
We don’t see that many Bachelor Nation alum being Traitors. Peter played a fantastic game from Bachelor Nation in season 2. We then had Gabby Windey who was a former Bachelorette win season 3 as a faithful. I’d love to see Charity in this traitor role especially since she’s so sweet in real life.
Kristen Doute
Original Show - The Valley
Also Seen On:
- Vanderpump Rules
What a mess. I’d love to see Kristen as a traitor. It would give Carolyn vibes from season 3. It would also pair her back with Alyssa Edwards and they had some issues on Amazon’s The Goat.
Kristen vs Alyssa: https://www.tiktok.com/@dylan.deckard/video/7367735251314953514?lang=en
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
The Faithfuls
1. Tiffany “New York” Pollard
Original Show - Flavor of Love
Also Seen On:
- I Love New York
- House of Villains
This has been long overdue. Tiffany “New York” Pollard is reality tv royality and we’ve seen that firsthand on House of Villains season 1 and 2. She would be crazy to watch as a faithful. Now with that being said she would only probably last a few episodes but those few episodes would be must see TV.
2. Tyson Apostol
Original Show - Survivor: Blood vs Water
- Tyson was originally on Survivor: Tocantins but won Survivor: Blood vs Water.
Tyson is one of the best players ever on Survivor and we saw that by how he was treated on Survivor: Winners at War in 2020. We’ve seen many Survivor players come and go like Parvati Shallow, Boston Rob, Tony Vlachos, and more. Funny enough, the only Survivor player who won Traitors was Cirie Fields who never won Survivor herself. Cirie played the best game as a Traitor so far. I’d love to see if Tyson can get another win under the belt of Survivors.
3. Nicole Franzel-Arroyo
Original Show - Big Brother 18
- Nicole was originally on Big Brother 16 but won Big Brother 18.
Nicole is one of the best Big Brother players of all-time. There is definitely an argument that she is the best of all-time. I feel like it’s just a waiting game at this point. I know some people would want her as a traitor but I feel like she’d get picked out early so I want to see her play the other side of the game.
4. Kordell Beckham
Original Show : Love Island USA 6
We needed some Love Island representation. The winner of the best season of Love Island should do. Kordell was a fan favorite and then a villain and then a fan favorite again on Love Island USA 6. I think Kordell is someone that could play a CT from season 2 type of game and get to the end and win.
5. NeNe Leakes
Original Show - The Real Housewives of Atlanta
Every season needs some housewives. Usually the housewives are taken out of the game fairly early but Dolores Catania from The Real Housewives of New Jersey broke that last year by winning the game. NeNe is one of the most well known housewives and would definitely bring some entertainment.
6. Bobby Lytes
Original Show - Love & Hip Hop Miami
Bobby really impressed me on House of Villains season 1. Not for his gameplay but for his drama. Bobby is another one that wouldn’t last long in the game but would instantly bring drama. I’d love to see him getting into arguments with New York (again), Jordan, and more.
7. Kathryn Dennis
Original Show - Southern Charm
Kathryn Dennis would the Queen of Southern Charm for years before she left the show. To be honest I don’t know how she would do on a competition type of reality show but I’d love to see it. I could see her playing a Gabby Windey.
7. Joey Graziadei
Original Show - The Bachelor 28
- Joey was originally on The Bachelorette 20 but was the lead on The Bachelor 28.
We need some Bachelor Nation representation. After Gabby Windey became the first member of Bachelor Nation to win Traitors last season and I could see Joey winning this potential one. Joey is a fan favorite and would probably be a fan favorite in this house too. I’d also love to see how he would play with Charity as a traitor.
8. Trisha Paytas
Original Show - YouTuber
This is a demographic Traitors needs to get into. YouTube has been a cultural phenomena for over a decade now and Trisha Paytas has been one of the biggest stars. I’d love to see how she would play this game, I’m assuming it’d be close to how she played Celebrity Big Brother a few years ago.
9. Jeff Teague
Original Show - Former NBA Player
To be honest I really don’t know what to expect with Jeff Teague. He seemed quiet as a player but since he has launched his podcast he has been hilarious. He is a true personality and I’d love to see how he’d play with some of these reality TV stars.
10. Teresa Giudice
Original Show - The Real Housewives of New Jersey
Traitors has been trying to get Teresa on the show for years. Apparently they were close for season 3 but she chose House of Villains instead and they then transferred to Dolores. I don’t think Teresa would be great at the game but she would definitely bring viewers in.
11. Callum Hole
Original Show - Love Island Australia 4
We need some more international Love Islanders especially after the iconic Phaedra Parks saying, “Oh Lord, Not Ekin-Su.” Callum was on Love Island Australia 4 and Love Island Games and is great TV.
12. Natalie Eva Marie
Original Show - Former WWE Superstar
Natalie Eva Marie was a WWE superstar. She also starred on Total Divas and Celebrity Big Brother. She is a big personality who is also super athlete. I think she would probably work with Kathryn Dennis and some of the other females just like Nikki Garcia, Chrishelle Stauss, and Gabby Windey worked together in season 3.
13. Derek Frazier
Original Show - Big Brother 23
I know a lot of people have various opinions on Derek Frazier but I want to see him on my TV again. I think Traitors would be the perfect show for him and I’d love to see how he would play as a faithful especially with all of these big personalities.
14. “JWoww” Jenni Farley
Original Show - Jersey Shore
Do we remember “you can stay and get you a** beat?” JWoww back in the day was one of the biggest reality stars of all-time. She is on Jersey Shore which used to average at least 10 million viewers an episode in its prime.
15. Russell Hantz
Original Show - Survivor: Samoa
Russell is one of the most notorious players in reality tv competition history. He used to burn his tribemates socks in Survivor. I thought about making him a Traitor but I thought that would be too easy for him. I want to see how he plays if he has to be a “Good Guy.”
16. Lilly Singh “IISUPERWOMANII”
Original Show - Youtuber
I mean let’s talk about YouTube royality. IISUPERWOMANII aka Lilly Singh was one of the faces of YouTube for years. If this hypothetical season were to happen and the faithful win Lilly would be my prediction to win.
17. Harry Jowsey
Original Show - Too Hot To Handle 1
I don’t know if Peacock would want to hire someone from Netflix, much less the poster boy of Netflix. Harry Jowsey is a legit celebrity and I’d love to see how he would play this game. To be honest I could see him being first boot.
18. Taylor Hale
Original Show - Big Brother 24
Taylor Hale is CBS’ poster child recently. She won Big Brother 24 after being harrassed and bullied all season. She came back and then got 2nd place on Big Brother: Reindeer Games. I think she would work with Nicole Franzel-Arroyo but I could see Taylor getting further.
19. Cory Wharton
Original Show - The Real World: Ex-Plosion / Back to San Francisco
Also Seen On:
- The Challenge
- Teen Mom 2
Cory is made for this show. He’s on almost every reality tv show already. I think he could potentially win as a faithful. I just don’t know how it would be with Jordan Wiseley as a Traitor. Jordan and Cory are friends and Jordan has attended Cory’s daughters birthday parties before.
20. Kelley Wentworth
Original Show - Survivor: San Juan Del Sur
We needed a woman from Survivor and Wentworth is the pick. She played 3 times and was so close to winning Survivor: Cambodia. I think she would be targeted early but to be honest she could win this show as well.
