Solitude and Intentionality of Attention
Why sitting in the woods can be a less contemplative space than a crowded subway car
Many of the ideas I’ve been thinking about lately came together on a recent episode of the Ezra Klein Show featuring Cal Newport, author of the forthcoming book Digital Minimalism.
The Ezra Klein Show
Listen to The Ezra Klein Show episodes free, on demand. Ezra Klein brings you far-reaching conversations about hard…
Klein says Newport is “making a bid to be the Marie Kondo of technology: someone with an actual plan for helping you realize the digital pursuits that do, and don’t, spark joy and bring value to your life.”
It’s an interesting connection—Newport is pushing us to get in touch with what uses of time help us live our values. To me, this echoes completely with my thoughts about the Six C’s. Are we consuming media when we intend to be connecting with others? Are we turning opportunities to cultivate ourselves into chores we need to power through?
Most importantly to Newport, it seems, is a more contemplative question: are we actually spending time communing with ourselves?
Newport uses a different word—solitude. But, as I’ve discussed, he makes it clear that solitude is not about whether you’re in a crowded room or on an empty beach. It’s about what you’re doing while you’re there.
You could be in a crowded room in silent personal contemplation, or on an empty beach listening to a podcast or scrolling through Twitter. True solitude, Newport says, is “freedom from inputs from other minds.” Communion, as I’ve written, is about connecting with oneself or with something bigger—turning off the consumption of other people’s thoughts and ideas.
E.B. White opens his essay Here is New York commenting specifically on how the bustling city offers this opportunity: “On any person who desires such queer prizes, New York will bestow the gift of loneliness and the gift of privacy.”
It’s true. I was recently on a serene beach for a six-day vacation, but I found myself persistently consuming books, podcasts, and other stimuli.
It wasn’t until I made an active decision to put the airpods down and walk to the edge of the water that I actually started communing with myself.
Even though it meant another week before I’d hear Newport’s podcast episode, it was well worth the wait.