The Fairy of the Prairie

Fender’s Blue Butterfly is Fluttering Back from the Brink of Extinction

By Jodie Delavan, Public Affairs Officer, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service — Oregon Fish and Wildlife Office

Fender’s blue butterfly resting on grass
Fender’s blue butterfly resting on grass. Photo credit: Oregon Department of Transportation

What does it take to save an endangered species? Faith, trust, and a little bit of pixie dust? Pardon the pun, but you don’t just “wing” it. There is a lot of time, planning, blood, sweat, tears, lessons learned, and teamwork involved in species recovery. And, okay, there might be a little “magic” in it too.

Fender’s blue butterfly (Icaricia icarioides fenderi) has experienced this magic firsthand. A member of the Lycadenidae (gossamer-wings) family, this butterfly was first described in 1931, based on a specimen collected west of Salem, Oregon.

Fender’s blue butterfly resting on kincaid’s lupine plant
Fender’s blue butterfly depends on three species of lupine throughout its life cycle, including the federally-threatened Kincaid’s lupine (Lupinus sulphureus kincaidii). Photo credit: Michelle St. Martin/USFWS

Much like a mythical fairy, little was known about this mysterious beauty. By 1937, Fender’s blue butterfly was nowhere to be found. Extinct, or so it seemed, until it was rediscovered a half century later by scientist, Dr. Paul Hammond.

The butterfly makes its home in the Willamette Valley’s upland prairies and oak savannahs. We partner closely with others to manage its landscape and monitor populations. Left: Finley National Wildlife Refuge prairie. Photo credit: George Gentry | Center: Biologist surveying for the species at a local vineyard. Photo credit: USFWS | Right: Old growth oak tree. Photo credit: Natural Resources Conservation Service

Fender’s blue butterfly is endemic to the Willamette Valley in northwest Oregon. Take a walk through the valley’s upland prairies and oak savannahs during May or June and you might be lucky enough to spot one. Maybe. These 1-inch wonders are often confused with the closely-related silvery blue butterflies (Glaucopsyche lygdamus). In fact, you can only really tell the difference by comparing the spotting pattern under their wings.

Butterfly resting on grass
There are color differences among the sexes of this species — the upper wings of males are brilliant blue with a blackish wing margin and a white fringe of scales whereas females are brown with a white fringe of scales. If you visit Finley or Baskett Slough National Wildlife Refuges between early May and late June, you very well could see this for yourself! Photo credit: Jeff Dillon/USFWS

Like other prairie-dependent species in the valley, Fender’s blue butterfly has weathered some hard times. Once abundant with prairies, wetlands, and upland oak habitat, the Willamette Valley has been largely altered by development and decades of fire suppression.

A number of prairie-dependent species once common in the Willamette Valley are challenged by habitat loss and invasive species. Left: Western meadowlark (Sturnella neglecta). Photo credit: Krista Lundgren/USFWS | Center: Overview of the Willamette Valley. Photo credit: Don Hankins/Flickr | Right: the federally-endangered Willamette daisy (Erigeron decumbens). Photo credit: West Eugene Wetlands Bureau of Land Management (BLM)

In 2000, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service listed Fender’s blue butterfly as endangered under the Endangered Species Act. At the time only 32 sites were known and its habitat was continuing to decline through the natural process of succession. By nature, prairies are transient communities, requiring disturbance to prevent them from turning into forests. With fire suppression, disturbances that previously maintained native prairies have been altered, allowing invasive weeds and native tree and shrub species to shade out low-growing lupine, a plant upon which this butterfly depends.

Trees and shrubs, along with invasive plants and grasses can outcompete native bunchgrasses and flowers. Left: old barn with scotch broom growing in the foreground. Photo credit: Bonnie Moreland | Center: Himalayan blackberry (Rubus armeniacus). Photo credit: Jared Smith/Flickr | Right: lupine competing with invasive tall grasses. Photo credit: USFWS

Over the past 20 years, the Service has worked diligently with landowners, conservation agencies, businesses, and other agencies in the region to conserve Fender’s blue butterfly. Together, we have restored and maintained habitat by mimicking natural disturbance through mowing, prescribed fire, and other methods. This disturbance is closely followed with seeding or planting plugs of this butterfly’s host plant and native flowers that provide nectar for this and other pollinators. This effort has been a major collaboration among a large group of diverse stakeholders –the Natural Resources Conservation Service, Bureau of Reclamation, Army Corps of Engineers, Willamette Valley National Wildlife Refuges, Benton County Parks, Institute of Applied Ecology, Washington State University, Greenbelt Land Trust, The Nature Conservancy, and numerous private landowners, among others.

Left: restored prairie at West Eugene Wetlands is home to over 200 species of wildflowers, plants, birds, and animals, including Fender’s blue butterfly, Kincaid’s lupine, Willamette daisy, and the recently recovered Bradshaw’s lomatium (Lomatium bradshawii). Photo credit: BLM |Right: Kincaid’s lupine plugs being planted by volunteers on a National Wildlife Refuge. Photo credit: USFWS

Thankfully, the planning, doing, learning, and sometimes redoing, is working because partnerships make conservation possible. The combination of prairie conservation, habitat management, and monitoring efforts has given Fender’s blue butterfly a “wing up.”

While the beauty and magic is in the partnerships, the evidence is in the numbers:

  • Fender’s blue butterfly now inhabits twice the acreage it did when listed as endangered in 2000;
  • Its known range has grown from four counties to six; and
  • The number of known occupied sites has quadrupled!
Left: Willamette Valley vineyard in the autumn. Photo credit: Bonnie Moreland | Right: volunteers working with USFWS staff to restore prairie habitat. Photo credit: George Gentry/USFWS

Another important number in this story is 95. More specifically, at least 95% of land within the Willamette Valley is privately owned, so voluntary, cooperative approaches are key to long-term conservation for this butterfly and other species. To date, 17 landowners have enrolled in Safe Harbor Agreements to help Fender’s and other prairie species and another dozen more agreements are in the works. Many of these landowners are working with Willamette Valley Refuges and the Partners for Fish and Wildlife Programs to improve and maintain prairie habitat on their private lands. It’s a beautiful partnership that brings collective resources to the table while providing management flexibility and regulatory certainty to landowners.

Rainbow over a meadow with trees
Rainbow over oak savannah at Finely National Wildlife Refuge. Photo credit: George Gentry/USFWS

Although Fender’s blue butterfly’s conservation story is not yet complete, these collaborative efforts have propelled this rare butterfly from near extinction to well on its way to recovery. Given a bit more time, and continued commitment to maintain and restore prairie habitat in the valley, this butterfly just might get its fairy-tale ending.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store