Why I won’t smile on command

Guys, please stop asking women to smile just because you’re around

Photo credit: Create Her Stock

I was walking back from the gas station, getting ready to fill up the gas tank of my U-Haul, when it happened. Just when I’d chosen my fuel type and lifted the pump, the guy on the other side leaned around to tell me: “You don’t have to look so mean. Smile more often.”

As someone who was recently told that I could take my “smile, box it up and sell it,” I am notorious for showing off the results of my electric toothbrush. But I don’t often smile when I’m out and about, running errands and just handling day-to-day life. This time specifically though, it rubbed me even more wrong than other days. I stared at Gas Pump Guy for a second, opened my mouth to respond and just thought better of it. It wasn’t his business to know why I wasn’t smiling nor did I owe him an explanation any more than I owed him a smile.

What that man didn’t know was I had rented this U-Haul to pick up a couple of large pieces of furniture from my grandfather’s house — who had specifically written down that I get this furniture in the event of his death. And he had died three days before that. A man I’d had in my life for over 35 years let me feed him and bathe him for a couple of months. Then one day, 15 minutes after I’d bathed and fed him, he died peacefully in his sleep.

Photo credit: GoranH/Pixabay

By no means did I feel like smiling that day or three days later at the gas station. All I wanted was something of his to be near me in my own home that he was adamant I receive. But the guy at the gas station who thought I looked “mean” and should “smile more often” didn’t know my grandfather nor me any more than he knows the person reading this right now.

He doesn’t know that I spent over four hours smiling and cracking jokes with my mother — whose birthday spa day happened to be the same day that my grandfather died. And I smiled on command for her because I love her, and I was determined that she have the absolute best birthday I could possibly provide for her. I sat in traffic on the way back and smiled. I pulled up to my grandfather’s house with her, where she thought she was getting out to visit him.

And she watched the smile on my face slowly fall and tears fall over my lips. But at no point during that day did she ever order me to smile, even on her birthday when I certainly should’ve been in a smiling mood.

Photo credit: Create Her Stock

And when my own mother, two months later, found out that she needed a pacemaker because her heart was beating too slow, I smiled again. I smiled all throughout the morning while she marched around getting her bags together. I smiled in the car. I smiled at her in the waiting area with my father before she was pushed away in the hospital bed. And I smiled at her when the doctor told my father and me that we could come in to the recovery area to see her. Because that smile was what I needed her to see to get through her day.

Photo credit: Create Her Stock

And 24 hours later when I returned to work, a man I know quite well saw me staring at my computer and tried to make conversation. I answered him politely but went back to working. And he came back around and said, “Do you need coffee or something? I just want to see you smile.”

And I hung my head again. Because this wasn’t a stranger. This wasn’t someone at the gas station. This was yet another man asking me to smile for no reason other than that he was in my presence.

Still though, I’m not quite sure why men request for women to smile so often. I don’t oppose smiling though. I’m a lover of laughter, a wise-cracking woman. I think any man who is funny is at least a five on a scale of 1–10, no matter what he looks like. I love funny men the way most women love tall, dark and handsome men. (I’m a big fan of the latter too.)

In a Psychology Today study, men are more likely to stand closer to a woman in an elevator if she smiles. And women are more likely to be attracted to the man who can make a group of men laugh versus guys who laugh at the joke starter.

Photo credit: StockSnap/Pixabay

I wholeheartedly understand the attraction. But it has never occurred to me to walk up to a frowning or scowling man to tell him why he needs to smile at me specifically. And in 35* years, I’ve never even seen a man walk up to another grown man (or boy) and tell him the same thing. And at some point, you have to wonder why. Why is it that men (sorry, guys, I just have never met a woman who demands that another woman smile at her) immediately feel entitled to a woman’s smile simply for being within her view?

Photo credit: (left) Cassandra Hamer/Unsplash, (right) Julian Howard/Unsplash

Now full disclosure, I’d like to believe that the two men in my examples above would’ve understood my downtrodden expression had I explained what had just happened with those two family members. But I just can’t erase the feeling of wanting to know: Why? Why is it that a woman must explain every single time she doesn’t smile? Better yet, when a man walks out of the door, does he have to explain why he’s not smiling every time he walks by every woman he sees? My guess is no.

If I see a man who looks like he needs to be alone with his thoughts, I kindly respect that. And I just admire from afar. If we make eye contact, cool. If not, there’s always another day.

Guys, the next time you want a woman to smile, just smile directly at her. Smiling is almost as contagious as yawning. She may not smile back for a variety of justifiable reasons, or maybe she will in spite of them. But if she wants to smile, she will do so — no request needed.

* This post was written two years ago. It has been edited and was originally published on The Good Men Project.

Would you like to receive Shamontiel’s Weekly Newsletter via MailChimp? Sign up today!

We Need to Talk

These heart-to-heart conversations challenge some unpopular views on family, relationships and activism.

Shamontiel L. Vaughn

Written by

15-year vegetarian journalist/editor; Wag! dog walker; Rover dog sitter; Toastmasters member and 5x officer; WERQ dance enthusiast; Visit Shamontiel.com

We Need to Talk

These heart-to-heart conversations challenge some unpopular views on family, relationships and activism.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade