The Truth Behind Authoritarian ‘Economic Miracles’
The Right-Wing Money Miracle Doesn’t Exist
We love a good economic miracle. The tale of a nation rising from the ashes, defying all odds to become an unstoppable juggernaut. It’s the stuff of legend, the kind of narrative that makes us believe anything is possible with the right leader, the right vision, and a dash of audacity.
But what if I told you that one of history’s most infamous “economic miracles” was actually a financial façade so fragile that it was destined to collapse under its own weight?
I’m not here to regurgitate dry facts or bore you with endless statistics. I want to talk about precisely what happens when irresponsible economics meet authoritarianism in a shit-show of self-obsessed, self-serving egonomics.
It’s 1933, and Germany is in shambles. The Great Depression has hit harder here than anywhere else in Europe. Banks are failing, unemployment is skyrocketing, and people are losing hope faster. Enter Adolf Hitler and his merry band of Nazi thugs, promising to Make Germany Great Again.
Now, here’s where things get interesting. Hitler and his crew pull off what seems like an economic miracle. In just a few short years, unemployment plummets, production soars, and Germany transforms from a broken nation into an industrial powerhouse. It’s the kind of turnaround that makes economists’ jaws drop and politicians green with envy.
And it was bullshit.
The Nazi economic “miracle” was about as real as a three-dollar bill. It was a carefully crafted illusion, a financial legerdemain so clever that it fooled an entire nation — and, for a time, nearly the whole world — into believing Germany was on the path to economic greatness.
So, how did they pull it off?
First up: Nationalism and Exceptionalism. The go-to of every authoritarian movement.
The Nazis skillfully used the concepts of Nationalism and Exceptionalism to force a brief economic resurgence. They played on deep-seated national pride and the humiliation from the Treaty of Versailles, promising to restore Germany to its former glory. By portraying Germans as a superior race destined for greatness, torn down by traitors in their own ranks (sound familiar?) and betrayed by other nations taking advantage of them (sound familiar?) they galvanized public support and justified extreme measures by paradoxically playing the victim and projecting dominance.
I’m just going to pause to let that sink in.
…
…
This fervent nationalism enabled the Nazis to rally the population around massive rearmament projects and infrastructure developments, creating jobs and reducing unemployment. The illusion of an economic miracle was bolstered by aggressive propaganda that depicted Germany as an unstoppable industrial power. It was a curtain of bullshit that hid the unsustainable and deceptive financial practices underpinning their so-called recovery.
Next up: MeFo bills.
MeFo bills were the secret sauce in Hitler’s economic recipe. Imagine if you could create money out of thin air, without anyone realizing it. That’s basically what MeFo bills were.
Here’s how it worked: The Nazis set up a dummy company called Metallurgische Forschungsgesellschaft (try saying that five times fast) or MeFo for short. This company would issue bills of exchange to pay for rearmament projects. Contractors could then take these bills to banks and exchange them for cold, hard cash.
Now for the good bit: These MeFo bills didn’t show up on the government’s official books. It was like having a secret credit card. The Nazis could spend billions on tanks, planes, and other military goodies without it looking like they were spending a dime.
But the Nazis also pulled off another neat trick: they co-opted private businesses into their batshit crazy economic scheme. Instead of nationalizing companies Soviet-style, they gave businesses “incentives” to play ball. And by incentives, I mean they basically told companies, “Hey, you can either invest in what we want, or we’ll make your life a living hell.”
Unsurprisingly, most businesses chose to go along with the Nazi program. They reinvested their profits into rearmament and other Nazi-approved projects, creating a façade of private sector growth that looked impressive on paper but was about as stable as a house of cards in an earthquake.
But that’s the thing about building your economy on lies and financial trickery: Eventually, reality catches up with you. And for Nazi Germany, reality was coming in hot.
By 1939, the cracks in the façade were starting to show. Remember those MeFo bills? Well, they were coming due, and the German government didn’t have the cash to pay them back. Oops.
To make matters worse, Germany’s foreign trade situation was a complete clusterfuck. You see, despite all their talk about self-sufficiency (or “autarky” if you want to sound fancy), Germany still needed to import a ton of food and raw materials. And nobody wanted to trade with them.
Why? Because the Nazi economics were about as trustworthy as a Nigerian prince offering you millions via email. It didn’t take long for the rest of the world to look at Germany’s financial practices and say, “Yeah, no thanks. We’ll pass.”
So, what did the Nazis do? They resorted to economic bullying, strong-arming smaller countries into unfavorable trade deals. It was like the economic equivalent of taking a kid’s lunch money, but on a national scale.
But even this wasn’t enough. By early 1939, Germany was facing severe shortages of pretty much everything. Food was scarce, raw materials were running low, and the average German was starting to wonder if this whole Nazi thing was really all it was cracked up to be.
The Nazi leadership knew they were in deep shit. They knew their economy was about to come crashing down to earth. So what did they do?
They doubled down.
Instead of admitting their mistakes and trying to fix the underlying issues, they fired anyone who dared to point out the problems (like Hjalmar Schacht, the economic mastermind behind the early Nazi “successes”) and replaced them with yes-men who would tell Hitler what he wanted to hear.
It’s like if you maxed out all your credit cards, and instead of trying to pay off your debt, you just applied for more credit cards and kept spending. Sure, it might work for a little while, but eventually, your luck runs out.
And that’s exactly what was happening to Nazi Germany on the eve of World War II. Their economy was a ticking time bomb, a financial disaster waiting to happen. The only thing keeping it afloat was the momentum of their earlier tricks and the iron fist of totalitarian control.
With mounting debts, dwindling resources, and a populace growing restless from shortages, Hitler and his cronies faced a stark reality: their economic sleight of hand had run its course. They needed a way out, and fast.
Enter the most fucked up solution imaginable: war.
Now, let’s be clear: war isn’t just hell, it’s also really, really expensive. But for the Nazis, it offered a twisted form of economic salvation. How? By allowing them to do what they do best: steal shit and exploit people.
War meant Germany could plunder the resources of conquered territories, solving their shortage problems. It meant they could use slave labor from occupied countries and concentration camps, cutting production costs. And it meant they could default on their debts and tear up trade agreements without consequence. Because who’s going to come collecting when you’ve got the Wehrmacht knocking at their door?
But using war as an economic strategy is like trying to put out a fire with gasoline. Ultimately, you’re just creating a bigger, more catastrophic blaze.
And that’s exactly what happened. The Nazi war machine initially seemed to solve Germany’s economic woes. They looted gold reserves from conquered nations, seized industrial resources, and forced millions into slave labor. For a brief, horrifying moment, it looked like their gambit might pay off.
But the cost of this “economic policy” was beyond staggering. We’re talking about the deaths of millions upon millions of people. Jews, Slavs, Roma, the LGBTQ, the disabled — the Nazis’ victims spanned across Europe and beyond. The Holocaust alone claimed six million Jewish lives, a number so large it’s almost impossible to comprehend.
And it wasn’t just those targeted by Nazi ideology who suffered. German civilians, soldiers from all sides, and countless innocents caught in the crossfire — the death toll of World War II is estimated at around 70–85 million people. That’s about 3% of the world’s population at the time, wiped out because a bunch of fascist assholes couldn’t admit their economic policies were bullshit.
The irony? In the end, this “policy” destroyed the very nation it was meant to save. Germany was left in ruins, its cities bombed to rubble, its population decimated, and its economy shattered beyond recognition.
The Nazis chose war as a way out of their economic hole because they’d backed themselves into a corner. They’d created a system so fundamentally unsound that only something as cataclysmic as global conflict could keep it afloat. And in doing so, they brought untold suffering upon the world.
So, what’s the takeaway from all this? What can we learn from the Nazi economic “miracle” that wasn’t?
Well, for starters, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is. The Nazi economic recovery defied all logic and economic principles. It should have set off alarm bells for anyone paying attention. But people wanted to believe in the miracle, so they ignored the warning signs.
Second, short-term gains always come at the expense of long-term stability. The Nazis boosted their economy through unsustainable methods, prioritizing immediate results over long-term health. If your economics require the deaths of millions to work, you might want to rethink your fucking strategy.
Third, transparency and accountability matter. The Nazi economy was built on deception and coercion. By hiding their true financial situation and strong-arming businesses and trading partners, they created a system that was doomed to fail. In economics, as in life, honesty really is the best policy.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, we need to be critical of economic “miracles.” It’s easy to get caught up in the hype of rapid growth and dramatic turnarounds. But as the Nazi example shows, what looks like a miracle on the surface might be a disaster waiting to happen underneath.
Economics isn’t just about numbers on a page or abstract theories. Economic decisions have real-world consequences, affecting the lives of millions. When leaders prioritize maintaining a façade of success over actual, sustainable growth, the results can be catastrophic.
There are no economic miracles. There’s just hard work, sound policies, and a whole lot of luck. Anything else is just a fantasy, a comforting lie we tell ourselves because we want to believe that there’s an easy way out of hard times.
But there isn’t. And the sooner we accept that, the sooner we can start building economies — and societies — that are truly strong, sustainable, and resilient. Not because of some mythical leader or magical economic policy, but because of the collective efforts of millions of people working together towards a common goal.
It’s not as flashy as the Nazi illusion, and it doesn’t make for exciting headlines. But it’s real, it’s lasting, and it’s the only kind of economic growth worth believing in.
The next time you hear about an economic miracle, whether it’s a country, a company, or even a get-rich-quick scheme, do yourself a favour and remember the Nazi economy.
Remember how an entire nation fooled itself into believing in an economic resurgence that was built on nothing but smoke, mirrors, murder and a whole lot of bullshit.
And then tell them to fuck off.
