The Case of Randy Carlyle

As of now, the Anaheim Ducks are still searching for a new head coach. In my previous article, I mentioned they have interviewed three candidates: MacLean, Yeo and Richardson. Most recently, the organization interviewed former NHL player Dale Hunter, who is currently head coach of the OHL’s London Knights. His no-nonsense style of coaching has helped the Knights become one of the league’s best and has helped in the development of the some the NHL’s young talent.

In my personal opinion, I believe that Dale Hunter would be a great fit for the Ducks.

Then two days ago, the team has interviewed a familiar face: Randy Carlyle.

Randy Carlyle is the winningest coach in the franchise’s history. In his six seasons with the Ducks, he posted a 273–182–61, which is very impressive. Due to his history with the team and because he has coached some of the players on the team: Perry, Getlzaf, Fowler and Cogliano, this is the main reason why the Ducks would consider bringing Carlyle back to Anaheim.

The biggest question, is it going to work?

There are a couple of things to consider if Carlyle returns to Anaheim.

The first thing is his style of coaching. He believes in playing a gritty style of hockey and that is something Anaheim is already familiar with. This is his biggest strength. He also utilizes heavy forechecking and the dump and chase. These are things the Ducks are familiar with and can make use of in the upcoming season. But bear in mind, the dump and chase was often criticized during Carlyle’s last season with the Ducks. It was a different team then. Maybe the Ducks’ current lineup of players will be able to execute it more efficiently this time around.

In addition to that, another thing people criticized about Carlyle is his lack of adjustments on the fly. This is perhaps his biggest weakness and it was apparent during his time with the Toronto Maple Leafs. The momentum and feel of a game can change at a drop of a hat. It is Carlyle’s responsibility to adjust his lineups when needed.

The second thing is his relationship with the players. In the beginning of the 2011–2012 season, the team struggled and upon his termination, Carlyle ended things on bad terms, namely with Getzlaf and Perry. It has been years since then and time heals all wounds. Well, most of them at least. In any case, this is something the organization is aware of and will be a big part of their decision making.

Looking at what Randy Carlyle has done for Anaheim organization, I believe in the Ducks time of need, his return is imminent. But until he reconciles with Getzlaf and Perry and everyone buries the hatchet, it will never happen.