Digitizing Prosperity:

Bridging the Divide for Inclusive Finance in Emerging Economies

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

In today’s rapidly evolving financial landscape, the relentless pace of digitalization is creating a chasm between those who have access to digital banking and the one-quarter of the world’s population that does not (United Nations,2023). The urgency of this issue stems from the digital banking revolution’s potential to fundamentally enhance economic participation, reduce social exclusion, and stimulate inclusive growth, which remains unrealized for many. This policy brief aims to envision a future where digital banking is a universal catalyst for economic inclusion, enabling every citizen to participate fully in the benefits of a digitized economy. Further, this brief aims to address the compelling need to universalize access to digital banking in these areas, not as a mere extension of financial services but as a fundamental tool for socio-economic transformation. This can be accomplished with a two-step approach: First, creating technological infrastructure that is trusted by the people and second, implementing solutions to enhance digital literacy that is both accessible and equitable.

“In 2021, the digital banking market in the U.S. was estimated at $4.3 billion, accounting for a 28.78% share of the global market.” — (World Bank, 2021)

The Problematic Persistence of the Digital Divide

The mandate to advance digital banking services is underpinned by a striking disparity: as per the World Bank’s Global Findex Database 2021, 1.7 billion adults remain unbanked, with the majority residing in underrepresented regions (The World Bank, 2021). The World Bank’s data illustrates a “digital divide” in which the impoverished, especially those living in isolated and rural regions, are not connected to the digital banking system. This gap is a sign of broader socioeconomic disparities and infrastructure that sustain financial exclusion rather than just a difference in access. Such an imbalance necessitates an urgent policy response — one that dismantles existing barriers and forges pathways for digital banking adoption. The depth of this inequality is made clear by the Global Findex statistics, which show that financial service account ownership in Subsaharan Africa is at roughly 55 percent with the global average being 76 percent (The World Bank, 2023). This division has farreaching effects, impeding the capacity for individual financial prosperity and the growth of the economy. It is clear that closing this gap requires more than just giving people access to financial services; it also entails making it possible for them to participate in the contemporary digital economy, which is essential for sustainable development (The World Bank, 2021).

Why is Digital Banking so important?

The urgency of addressing this divide is rooted in the transformative potential of digital banking to enhance quality of life and stimulate economic development. Digital banking provides underserved populations with the means for secure financial transactions, access to credit, and the ability to save and invest, thereby fostering financial independence and stability. A report by the University of Washington elucidates the direct correlation between the implementation of digital banking and the enhancement of economic development, illustrating that as banking services become more accessible through digital platforms, they catalyze economic participation and growth among disadvantaged segments (University of Washington, 2023). Further, the report The Future of Digital Financial Inclusion underscores the pivotal role of digitized payments in supporting social welfare initiatives. The ability of governments to disseminate aid such as tax credits and unemployment benefits through digital channels has been a game-changer, ensuring timely and secure support to those in need (CSIS, 2022). This mechanism has been particularly crucial during the COVID-19 pandemic, where digital payments have facilitated the immediate and contactless distribution of financial aid, reinforcingthe necessity of digital financial infrastructure in crisis response.

“Populations that are locked out of the formal digital economy are often deprived of technological empowerment, tend to be exploited through higher fees and can face exposure to more intermediaries as well as higher-risk systems.” — Rama Sridhar, Forbes Council Member

The IMF working paper Digital Financial Inclusion in Emerging and Developing Economies: A New Index offers a comprehensive assessment of fintech’s evolution and its varying degrees of adoption across different regions. Introducing a novel digital financial inclusion index, which is a critical analytical tool that measures the progress of fintech adoption takes into account both access to and usage of digital financial services (IMF, 2021). It reveals that fintech has been instrumental in driving financial inclusion, with regions such as Africa, Asia, and the Pacific witnessing the most considerable progress. This variance highlights the asymmetric nature of fintech’s proliferation, prompting a call for targeted strategies that address regional disparities in digital banking adoption.

Reasons for Current Barriers:

For emerging economies, the journey to digital banking is fraught with obstacles that vary across geography and demographics. These barriers are multifaceted and deeply entrenched, posing significant challenges to widespread adoption. First, the lack of fundamental technological infrastructure, such as stables internet access and electricity, remains a towering barrier.

These deficiencies are particularly acute in rural areas, where the infrastructure for basic connectivity is often inadequate or completely absent, rendering digital banking services inaccessible. For example, in Latin America, cost is a significant impediment, with nearly 60% of the unbanked citing it as the main reason for not having a bank account (University of Washington, 2023).

Similarly, literacy barriers can be surmounted through targeted educational initiatives that equip individuals with the knowledge and confidence to navigate digital financial services. In many emerging economies, less than 50% of adults have access toan account at a financial institution or through a mobile money provider (The World Bank, 2021). Digital literacy is a pivotal factor in the transition to digital banking, yet for many, especially the elderly and less educated, the digital world is a labyrinth of complexity. This lack of familiarity and comfort with digital tools is a formidable barrier, preventing a significant portion of the population from engaging with digital banking services. In this context, the rationale for action is both clear and compelling. To bridge the digital divide in banking, it is essential to adopt policy measures that foster an inclusive digital financial ecosystem that will act as an engine of equitable economic growth.

Extending Digital Banking Access to All: A Two-Part Approach

Overview: A two-part approach to bridging the digital divide is necessary in order to build a technological infrastructure that can support worldwide adoption while ensuring individuals are digitally literate.

STEP 1: Improving Technological Infrastructure and Instilling Trust

As a lever for social and economic advancement, the creation of a strong technology infrastructure is essential to the equitable adoption of digital banking. Currently, digital banking services are largely inaccessible due to a lack of such infrastructure, particularly broadband internet connectivity, and a lack of accessible banking applications. Further, the infrastructure must coincide with an element of trust.

A: Broadband Internet Connectivity

Broadband internet connectivity is not merely a technological amenity but a conduit for socio-economic empowerment. A study by the World Bank correlates every 10% increase in high-speed internet connections with a 1.3% growth in economic output, underscoring the profound impact of connectivity on economic vitality (The World Bank, 2020).

By extending broadband coverage to underserved areas, we can bridge the digital divide, enabling regions that have traditionally lagged to partake in the digital economy. The ripple effects of broadband connectivity are manifold: it facilitates access to online financial services, including digital banking, which is crucial for fostering financial inclusion. Enhanced connectivity also democratizes access to online marketplaces, enabling rural entrepreneurs and small businesses to reach broader markets, leading to increased revenue and growth. For instance, a report by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) observed that small businesses with high levels of internet use report up to 22% higher revenue growth than those with low internet usage (ITU, 2020).

B: Development of Accessible Banking Apps

The widespread adoption of mobile technology offers a pathway to financial inclusion through banking apps that accommodate low bandwidth and user-friendly design, essential in areas with limited internet access. The M-PESA model in Kenya exemplifies how such services can elevate financial inclusion for low-income users (MIT News, 2016). Encouraging the development of these apps, governments can offer tax breaks, and grants, or establish regulatory sandboxes for piloting new technologies. These apps must cater to diverse literacy levels and include multilingual support and intuitive navigation.

Initiatives like The Bank of Indonesia’s program is exemplary in enhancing financial inclusivity through innovative measures tailored for individuals with limited literacy. By integrating user friendly digital interfaces that utilize simple iconography and voice-assisted technology, the program enables easier access to banking services for those who struggle with traditional, text-heavy financial systems. Additionally, it conducts targeted educational campaigns in local languages to build digital financial literacy, ensuring that even those previously excluded from the banking sector can confidently engage with these essential services (World Economic Forum, 2022). The primary challenge lies in extending infrastructure to remote locations, which can be addressed through innovative financing like public private partnerships and integrated development strategies, ensuring that digital banking catalyzes broader community development and resilience.

C. Instilling Trust

Lastly, the foundation of any successful financial system is trust. In digital banking, where interactions are devoid of face-to-face engagement, establishing and maintaining trust is paramount. Building confidence in digital banking requires a two-pronged approach: a robust regulatory framework that ensures the security and reliability of services, and proactive measures to inform and educate users about the benefits and safeguards of digital banking.

A regulatory framework that aligns with international best practices provides a structured approach to overseeing digital banking services. Such a framework not only ensures that financial institutions adhere to high security and operational standards but also offers consumers reassurance that their interests are protected. The establishment of a regulatory body or the enhancement of existing regulatory capacities to specifically address digital banking is essential.

“Innovation is the ability to see change as an opportunity, not a threat.” — Steve Jobs

STEP 2: Enhancing Digital Literacy

The digital divide is not insurmountable; it can be effectively bridged by equipping the populace with essential digital skills. Digital literacy transcends the basic use of technology; it encompasses a comprehensive understanding and application of digital tools to access economic opportunities and financial services. This literacy fosters an environment where digital banking is not an alien concept but a familiar, accessible tool for everyday financial transactions.

A: Community-Based Training Initiatives

The impact of community-based training initiatives on enhancing digital literacy rates is substantial and well-documented. Evidence from localized workshops, such as those that have increased the adoption of digital payment systems in countries with traditionally low digital engagement, underscores the effectiveness of these programs. The McKinsey report (2022) cites significant improvements in nations like Kenya and India, where community-focused training has been instrumental in familiarizing populations with digital financial services. These initiatives have been particularly successful by centering on practical skills and the real-world applicability of digital tools, thus demystifying the technology and making it more approachable for the average user (McKinsey, 2022). An initiative reported by the World Economic Forum (2023) further illustrates the transformative potential of such programs, specifically within India’s rural communities. It has established a framework for measuring digital literacy skills, enabling not just the acquisition of these skills by participants but also the dissemination of this knowledge to the children under their care. This program’s approach is particularly noteworthy because it catalyzes a cycle of continuous learning and skill sharing, which is essential for sustained digital engagement. found skills to the children in their communities.

Its systematic approach to assessing digital literacy is commendable for initiating a perpetual cycle of education and skill transfer, a critical element for ongoing digital participation. By pooling training materials, ensuring internet accessibility, and providing instructional expertise, these alliances guarantee a comprehensive and inclusive approach to digital literacy that extends its benefits to wider sections of the population. Not only does it bolster their capabilities, but it also positions them to be vectors of change and knowledge in bridging the digital divide.

B. Educational Integration

Embedding digital banking education within formal schooling is crucial for cultivating financial digital proficiency. Emulating Singapore’s model, which successfully integrated fintech education into secondary school curriculums, can ensure a generation adept in navigating the financial tech landscape (Statista, 2023). These educational strategies extend beyond skill development; they address financial disparities, notably by empowering women and girls with theknowledge for economic self-sufficiency. Rwanda’s Ihuzo project highlights the positive outcomes of such focused literacy efforts, enhancing female entrepreneurship and engagement in digital commerce (UN Women, 2023).

Effective educational modules combine hands-on digital banking exercises with essential financial concepts, equipping individuals to confidently utilize digital services and make informed financial decisions. Despite the potential, integrating digital financial literacy into education systems is not without challenges — consistent funding, fair access, and keeping pace with technological change are hurdles to be navigated. Addressing these obstacles requires forming strategic partnerships with technology companies for resource sharing, employing mobile technology to extend educational reach, and designing curricula that evolve through regular updates and active feedback mechanisms. These strategic educational measures are pivotal for promoting financial inclusion and preparing upcoming generations for active participation in a digitally-inclined economy.

“In today’s digital world, digital literacy is as important as traditional literacy.” — Nicky Verd

SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS

STEP 1: Establish and Reinforce Technological and Regulatory Infrastructure

• Broadband Internet Connectivity: Expand broadband infrastructure to facilitate access, particularly in underserved regions, enhancing the reach and reliability of digital banking services. This expansion is critical for enabling seamless access to digital financial platforms, fostering economic activities, and improving quality of life through connected services.
• Accessible Banking Apps: Encourage the development of user-friendly, low-bandwidth banking apps, ensuring they are navigable for individuals with varying levels of literacy and technological proficiency. This will be vital for empowering users, especially in remote areas with limited connectivity, to participate in the digital economy.
• Regulatory Framework and Trust: Establish a robust regulatory framework that ensures the security and operational reliability of digital banking services. This framework should include measures to protect consumer data and prevent fraud, thereby building trust in digital financial systems.

STEP 2: Boost Digital Literacy and Financial Education

• Community-Based Training: Implement localized digital literacy initiatives in collaboration with stakeholders to familiarize individuals with digital banking tools. These initiatives should prioritize practical skills and real-world applications, making digital banking more approachable and relevant to users’ daily lives.
• Integrate Digital Banking Education: Incorporate digital financial literacy into formal education systems to foster a generation adept in digital banking and financial management. This integration should aim to provide equitable education that empowers young individuals, particularly women and girls, to achieve financial autonomy.

STEP 3: Create Inclusive Digital Banking Ecosystems

• Tailored Financial Services: Design digital banking services that address the specific needs of all user demographics, including marginalized communities. This involves making digital banking more affordable and crafting services that resonate with users’ cultural contexts and economic realities.
• Monitor and Adapt: Continuously evaluate the impact and uptake of digital banking services to identify areas for improvement. Adapt policies and programs in response to feedback and emerging trends, ensuring that the digital banking ecosystem remains inclusive, responsive, and sustainable.

REFERENCES:

1. How one bank is digitizing financial inclusion in Indonesia. World Economic Forum. (2022, May 23). https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/05/digitalization-financial-inclusion-in-indonesia/
2. Jerenz, A. (2022, September 8). Winning in digital banking. McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/tech-forward/winning-in-digitalbanking
3. Khera, P., Ng, S. Y., Ogawa, S., & Sahay, R. (2021, March 19). Digital Financial Inclusion in emerging and developing economies: A new index. IMF Working Papers. https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2021/03/19/Digital-Financial-Inclusion-in-Emerging-and-Developing-Economies-A-New-Index-50271
4. Leal, E., & Bandura, R. (2022, September 29). The future of Digital Financial Inclusion. The Future of Digital Financial Inclusion. https://features.csis.org/future-of-digital-financial-inclusion/
5. Matheson, R. (2016, December 8). Study: Mobile-money services lift Kenyans out of poverty. MIT News . https://news.mit.edu/2016/mobile-money-kenyans-out-poverty-1208
6. Sridhar, R. (2021, September 14). Council post: Bridging the digital divide is key to building financial inclusion. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbesbusinessdevelopmentcouncil/2021/09/10/bridging-the-digital-divide-is-key-to-building-financial-inclusion/?sh=18513da675ae
7. Statista Research Department . (2023, December 21). Fintech in Singapore — statistics and facts. Statista. https://www.statista.com/topics/9449/fintech-in-singapore/#topicOverview
8. The World Bank. (2021). The Global Findex Database 2021. https://www.worldbank.org/en/publication/globalfindex
9. United Nations. (2023, September 15). E-commerce platform bridges the Digital Gender Divide in Rwanda. UN Women. https://www.unwomen.org/en/news-stories/feature-story/2023/09/e-commerceplatform-bridges-the-digital-gender-divide-in-rwanda
10. World Bank Group. (2023, October 6). Digital Financial Inclusion in Africa interview series Tim Masela. World Bank. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2023/09/26/digital-financial-inclusionin-africa-interview-series-tim-masela#:~: text=DFI%20is%20the%20ability%20of,global%20average%20of%2076%20percent United Nations. (2023, October 6).
11. Widening Digital Gap between developed, Developing States threatening to exclude world’s poorest from Next Industrial Revolution, speakers tell Second Committee | Meetings Coverage and press releases. United Nations. https://press.un.org/en/2023/gaef3587.doc.htm
12. Wilson, I. (2023, August 7). Digital Banking and Economic Development: Inclusion and exclusion in Latin America. The Henry M. Jackson School of International Studies. https://jsis.washington.edu/news/digital-banking-and-economic-development-inclusion-and-exclusionin-latin-america/