The Greatest Gift You Can Give

How a difficult feedback changed my life

Ilam Padmanabhan
Writing Magic
Published in
3 min readMay 29, 2022

--

Feedback is the best gift ever! Photo - Towfiqu barbhuiya

Post 247/500

A short (true) story first!

I was working in London at the time.

A senior director (let’s call him Mr. H) walked across my desk and wanted to have a chat.
Knowing how busy he was, I knew this had to be something important.

He walked into the meeting room without waiting for me.
I thought, “this must be serious. “ I took my notebook and followed him into the room. I was a bit nervous and forgot my pen. Luckily the meeting room had one.

He didn’t speak for about 30 seconds.

My heartbeat went up. I could see that he wasn’t finding it easy.

He sat slightly uncomfortable. The silence finally broke.

He politely said, “I’ve heard complaints about your personal hygiene. “

I was taken aback. I said, “sorry, what?”.

He explained that some colleagues who sat around my cubicle had complained about my personal hygiene.

The short message was that they could smell me, and it wasn’t pleasant.

I was in a bit of shock but eventually broke out of it. I politely thanked him for the feedback and came out of the meeting room.

I was angry! I was breathing fire!
How can anyone care? And even complain to my boss..do they have nothing else to worry about in life..
This is so unfair..etc., etc

I calmed down after a while and played it back.

It was the worst feedback ever, by country miles. It was a personal attack, or I felt like it.

But it was also the best feedback ever. It revealed to me something I hadn’t even known to think about.

Maybe it was the spicy food or sweat forced out of my body in London Tubes.
I was smelling, and I didn’t know it.
Someone sitting in the next cubicle could smell me. But I couldn’t. That is when I realized my sense of smell wasn’t strong.

--

--

Clear is Kind — What does that mean in the workplace?

3 min read

Oct 24, 2019

Direct Reports and Radical Candor: 5 Tips for Giving Guidance and Feedback

13 min read

Apr 7, 2020

How to Deliver Constructive Feedback in Difficult Situations

9 min read

Sep 30, 2018

Hate delivering negative feedback at work? 19 phrases to help make giving difficult feedback easier

5 min read

Feb 10, 2020

4 Strategies to Give Effective Feedback to a Difficult Person

8 min read

Sep 1, 2022

Ilam Padmanabhan
Writing Magic

Love to read and write about Software Engg, Agility, QA, Future of Humanity, AI, Books, Travel, Politics, Climate Change, Personal Finance, Writing & Life!