Top 5 Alternative Economies: Beyond Money and Capitalism

Grayson Winters ☦️
6 min readApr 3, 2023

--

Are you tired of the money-driven culture that has taken over our society? I sure am. That’s why I’m eager to delve into the topic of alternative economies in this piece. In my previous article, I highlighted the dangers of prioritizing wealth and possessions above all else, and shared the heartbreaking story of my friend, who lost his life in pursuit of material success. It’s clear that we need to reevaluate our priorities and find meaning beyond the accumulation of money and possessions.

Photo by Jp Valery

That’s where alternative economies come in. In this article, I’ll be taking a closer look at five of the most popular non-monetary economic models that have emerged as potential solutions to the problems of capitalism. From gift economies to commons-based peer production, these models have the potential to shift the way we think about value and exchange, and to prioritize the well-being of individuals and communities over profit and growth. So join me as we explore these promising models and consider the possibilities they hold for a brighter future.

Gift Economy

Let’s start with the concept of the gift economy! This economic model is all about giving without expecting anything in return. Imagine if your friend gave you a gift for your birthday and you didn’t have to get them anything in return. Wouldn’t that be great? Well, in a gift economy, that’s exactly how things work!

The gift economy has been around for centuries and was practiced by many indigenous cultures before modern capitalism took over. It was also proposed by a number of thinkers and philosophers, including Marcel Mauss and Lewis Hyde. Unlike current capitalism, which is based on the accumulation of wealth and possessions, the gift economy is all about sharing and giving. It doesn’t rely on money or markets to determine value, but rather on relationships and social connections.

One of the main benefits of a gift economy is that it can help to create stronger, more supportive communities. Instead of everyone looking out for themselves and trying to get ahead, people work together to help each other out. This can lead to greater social cohesion and a sense of belonging. However, the gift economy is not without its challenges. For example, it can be difficult to ensure that everyone is giving and receiving equally, and there is the risk that some people may take advantage of the system. Nonetheless, the gift economy is a fascinating alternative to traditional capitalism that is definitely worth exploring!

Resource Based Economy

Next in line, one of my favorites is the Resource-Based Economy. It’s an alternative economic model that aims to create a sustainable society through the efficient management of resources. The idea was proposed by Jacque Fresco, an American futurist and social engineer who founded The Venus Project.

Image by The Venus Project

The Resource-Based Economy is a complete departure from the current capitalist system. Instead of profit being the driving force of the economy, the focus is on the needs of the people and the planet. The economy is managed by computer systems that track resource availability and consumption, which are then used to plan and allocate resources accordingly. This system would eliminate the need for money altogether, as all goods and services would be freely accessible to everyone.

This model proposes a new vision for society, where technology and innovation are utilized to create a sustainable, equitable, and abundant future. With its emphasis on collaboration, efficiency, and sustainability, this economic model offers an alternative to the problems inherent in capitalism, such as resource depletion, inequality, and environmental degradation.

Participatory Economics

Moving on, let’s discuss Participatory Economics. It is an alternative economic model that focuses on the participation of everyone in the economy, unlike the current capitalist system where only a few have the power to make decisions. It was proposed by Michael Albert and Robin Hahnel in the 1990s as a solution to the problems of capitalism. The basic idea of participatory economics is that people should be involved in decision-making in all aspects of the economy, including production, consumption, and distribution.

In this model, decision-making is done through a system of councils and committees, where everyone has an equal say in how things are run. The economy is organized into self-managed workplaces and communities, with workers having a say in the decisions that affect their lives. Participatory Economics seeks to eliminate the problems of capitalism such as inequality and exploitation by giving everyone an equal voice in economic decision-making.

Commons-Based Peer Production

Another popular alternative economic model is Commons-based peer production. It is a type of economic system that focuses on collaboration and shared resources. This model was proposed by scholars Yochai Benkler and Aaron Shaw, who suggested that information technology could be used to bring people together to work on common goals. It is based on the idea that resources should be shared freely and openly, rather than being controlled by a select few.

Photo by viarami

In commons-based peer production, people work together to create and share knowledge, software, and other intellectual resources. This type of production is not driven by profit, but rather by the desire to create something valuable for the community. This system differs from current capitalism in that it prioritizes collaboration and sharing over competition and individual ownership. Commons-based peer production is often associated with open-source software, where programmers work together to develop and improve software that can be freely used by anyone. By sharing resources and working together, this alternative economy seeks to create a more equitable and sustainable system that benefits everyone.

Circular Economy

Last but not least, we have the Circular Economy, which is a way of thinking about our economy that’s all about reusing and recycling resources instead of just using them once and throwing them away. The idea is to keep resources in use for as long as possible and to minimize waste.

This economic model was proposed by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and it’s been gaining a lot of attention in recent years. The concept is to move away from the traditional linear “take-make-dispose” model of production and consumption and create a more sustainable economy. In a circular economy, products are designed to be reused or recycled, and waste is seen as a valuable resource rather than something to be thrown away.

This model is different from current capitalism in that it prioritizes sustainability over growth and profit. It seeks to create a regenerative and restorative economy rather than one that just takes resources from the earth and uses them up. By embracing circular economy principles, we can reduce waste, conserve resources, and minimize our impact on the environment. This is a model that has the potential to create a more sustainable future for all of us.

In conclusion, it is important to recognize that the implementation of alternative economic models will not happen overnight. It requires a significant shift in the mindset of our leaders and society as a whole. However, the fact that these models already exist and have been developed provides hope for a brighter future. It is up to us to spread awareness and advocate for change, and to support organizations and communities that are actively working towards implementing these models.

Photo by shameersrk

Every system has its own advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to consider them all when evaluating the feasibility of implementing an alternative economic model. But one thing is for sure — we cannot continue on our current path of prioritizing profit over people and the planet. As individuals, we have the power to make a difference and push for change. With awareness and action, we can move towards a more sustainable, equitable, and just economic system. Thank you for taking the time to learn about these alternative models, and let’s continue to work towards a brighter future!

--

--