The Weekly Arc: April 28, 2017
Welcome to Arc’s newsletter, sent out once per week, highlighting the best and most interesting stories from around the web.
Trump’s Tax Proposal
The AP, via the White House, on Trump’s tax plan:
Trump’s First 100 Days
Under the politics section, we include lots of analyses of Trump’s First 100 Days. Don’t forget to read those.
The House GOP was kind enough to tweet out one of our pieces on this very topic:
Whatever you think of this arbitrary marker in a president’s first term, it does seem to give us a chance to make some early assessments about a presidency’s effectiveness coming out of the gate.
Confederate Monuments
On Monday, the city of New Orleans began the process of removing its four major Confederate monuments. …
This is a good thing.
The Federalist’s John Daniel Davidson disagrees, writing Tuesday that despite assurances to the contrary, this is not about “unity or tolerance,” but about “power and politics.” …
Davidson is right to notice that, for some, the application of both kinds of censorship — toward monuments and toward speeches — stems from the same illiberal impetus. …
[But…]
I applaud New Orleans’ decision to remove — and eventually relocate — its Confederate monuments because I make a distinction between backward-looking and forward-looking monuments.
Backward-looking monuments are those specifically intended to teach the lessons of history. Forward-looking ones can also memorialize, and can reflect historical realities, but they have an additional feature that backward-looking ones do not: Forward-looking monuments promote our core values and herald American virtues.
Forward-looking monuments are those we use to proclaim what is best about us, to signal who we are and to project into the future who we will continue to be. These are the ones we canonize because embedded within them is the set of virtues we wish to continue to be associated with.
Viewing monuments this way allows for historical reflection as well as moral striving. As an approach to our national iconography, it strikes a balance between an extreme self-flagellation over our past sins (“we have always been terrible”) and an ahistorical jingoism unwilling to acknowledge any past transgression at all (“we have never been terrible”). There is value in looking back and value in looking ahead. And history, despite its association with the past, furnishes us with the symbols we need for both sorts of activity.
Museums should hold those artifacts whose original usage we find problematic today. A statue erected in a city space, on the other hand, is a paradigmatic example of a forward-looking monument — one that is supposed to herald something about us moving forward.
Another way of putting it is that some monuments are primarily pedagogical and others are primarily presentational.
Here is my thesis: For its self-presentation, America should utilize only images and symbols that promote our core values. Our iconography should embody American virtues, not challenge them. These should be the monuments we use to project into the future who and what we are striving to be.
Fyre Festival of Horrors
In early March, a friend of mine texted me to ask if I wanted to be a talent producer for the Fyre Festival. I’d never heard of it, but the gig involved going to the Bahamas and being paid extremely well. So I said yes and packed my bags. The festival was supposed to be a luxury music retreat where elite millennials could mingle with “influencers” and models. Tickets cost between $1K and $125K, gourmet food and accommodations were promised. I was planning to spend the next two months working on the festival, but a mere four days after I arrived I was back on a plane to New York because the whole thing, as everyone now knows, was a complete disaster. I was briefly involved in the planning of the event and got a front-row seat to chaos.
On March 14, I flew from Miami to the island of Great Exuma to get the planning started. I was excited, at least at first. Flying in, the water looked beautiful — but I was almost immediately warned not to go near it because of a rampant shark problem. That was an omen I regrettably missed.
After we landed, we drove to the festival site to assess our goods. When we arrived, my initial reaction was “huh.” This was not a model-filled private cay that was owned by Pablo Escobar. This was a development lot covered in gravel with a few tractors scattered around. There was not enough space to build all the tents and green rooms they would need. There was not a long, beautiful beach populated by swimming pigs. There were, however, a lot of sand flies that left me looking like I had smallpox. Still, I had hope.
My job as a talent producer was to coordinate travel and on-site logistics with the artists who would be performing: Blink 182, Major Lazer, Disclosure, among others, had already signed on. I would be working with an 11-person team and a few of the festival executives. The production team was all new hires and, before we arrived, we were led to believe things had been in motion for a while. But nothing had been done. Festival vendors weren’t in place, no stage had been rented, transportation had not been arranged. Frankly, we were standing on an empty gravel pit and no one had any idea how we were going to build a festival village from scratch.
Pending disaster aside, I started working from an island rental house. I contacted the booked artists’ tour managers to start to coordinate. Almost all of them had the same question for me, which was along the lines of, “Hey … Where’s our money??” I tried to email the business manager to get an answer, who said something like “stand by” for three days in a row. By the end of the week it became clear they would not pay the people they owed.
On Wednesday, Ja Rule arrived for a “site visit.” I don’t know if he actually visited the “site” but he did spend a lot of time on a yacht, according to his Instagram. Meanwhile the event planners were holed up indoors putting together a game plan and a budget. With so little having been prepared ahead of time, the official verdict was that it would take $50 million to pull off. Planners also warned that it would be not be up to the standard they had advertised. The best idea, they said, would be to roll everyone’s tickets over to 2018 and start planning for the next year immediately. They had a meeting with the Fyre execs to deliver the news. A guy from the marketing team said, “Let’s just do it and be legends, man.”
How was Chloe Gordon, the author of this excellent New York Magazinepiece, able to discuss all of these things openly? The Fyre Festival management forgot to have her sign a Non-Disclosure Agreement!
Read the whole thing here.
Want to support Arc? Please take a second to like and follow us on these accounts. It genuinely helps us.
- It Could Be Worse by Ross Douthat (The New York Times)
- The Education of Donald Trump by Josh Dawsey, Shane Goldmacher, and Alex Isenstadt (Politico)
- A Hundred Days of Trump by David Remnick (The New Yorker)
- Trump’s First 100 Days Were More Effective Than You Think by Charlie Gerow (Arc)
- How Do You Solve a Problem?: North Korea by Nicholas Grossman (Medium)
- Why Can’t House Repeal Obamacare? Because a lot of Republicans Don’t Want To. by Byron York (The Washington Examiner)
- Donald Trump Is a Real Republican, and That’s a Good Thing by Charles R. Kesler (The New York Times)
- A New Report Reveals Obama Misled the Public About a Quiet Giveaway to Iran by Zeeshan Aleem (Vox)
- Florida Voted for Medical Marijuana. State Legislators Don’t Care. by Tho Bishop (Arc)
- Macron, Le Pen, and the Limits of Nationalism by Gideon Rachman (Financial Times)
- How Trump Blew Up the Conservative Media by Eliana Johnson (Politico)
- So How is the Trump Era Working Out for Paul Ryan? by Paul Waldman (The Week)
- Will Political Normality Return in 2017? by David Frum (The Atlantic)
- Rod Dreher’s Monastic Vision by Joshua Rothman (The New Yorker)
- Indexing Political Theologies: Six Christianity and Culture Strategies by Jake Meador (Mere Orthodoxy)
- Why Educated Christians Are Sticking With Church by Emma Green (The Atlantic)
- Who’s In Charge of the Christian Blogosphere? by Tish Harrison Warren (Christianity Today)
- Bill Nye Instructs Us All: Stop Having Kids by Owen Strachan (Center for Public Theology)
- God-Centered Dogmatics: John Webster’s “Principles of Systematic Theology” by Scott Swain (Sapienta)
- If it Doesn’t Stem its Decline, Mainline Protestantism has Just 23 Easters Left by Ed Stetzer (The Washington Post)
- Confederate Monuments Belong in Museums, Not Public Squares by Berny Belvedere (The Weekly Standard)
- The Crisis of Western Civ by David Brooks (The New York Times)
- The Global Elite Are Headed for a Fall. And They Don’t Even Know It. by Damon Linker (The Week)
- How to Pop the Political Bubbles Keeping Americans Apart by Michael Gerson (The Washington Post)
- Capitalism Defeats Bill O’Reilly by Nicholas Grossman (Arc)
- Celebrating Transgender Diversity Requires Solid Gender Roles by Leslie Loftis (The Federalist)
- My Comeback on Trump, Le Pen, Brexit, Climate Change… by Simon Kuper (Financial Times)
- Apparently I’m Stigmatizing Domestic Work by Not Being Ashamed to Do It by Rachel Darnall (Iron Ladies)
- Bill Nye and the Politics of Grievance by Ben Domenech (The Federalist)
- Abortion Rift Puts Democratic Militants in Charge by Eric Fehrnstrom (The Boston Globe)
- Should You Kill Your Child To Save The World? by Berny Belvedere (The Federalist)
- Trump Rides a Market Wave, but Business Looks for Results by Nelson D. Schwartz, Patricia Cohen, and Landon Thomas Jr. (The New York Times)
- Of Malls and Mills by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Trump’s Tax Plan Looks Like A Plutocrat’s Dream by John Cassidy (The New Yorker)
- Trump’s Tax Plan is Brilliant Politics and Even Better Economics by Jeffrey A Tucker (The Foundation for Economic Education)
- Nation-States vs City-States by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Trump’s Tax Proposal Is Just a Symptom of the Disease by Megan McArdle (Bloomberg View)
- ESPN Is A Reminder That When It Comes To The Market, No One Is Too Big To Fail by Tho Bishop (Arc)
- France is the Weakest of Europe’s Big 3 Economies by Ivana Kottasova (CNN Money)
- The IMF’s Rosy Economic Picture by Berny Belvedere (Arc)
- Can Facebook Fix Its Own Worst Bug? by Farhad Manjoo (The New York Times Magazine)
- The Problem With WikiTribune by Adrienne LaFrance (The Atlantic)
- Inside the Retail Store of the Future by Robert Williams and Jeremy Kahn (Bloomberg Technology)
- We’re In An Artificial Intelligence Hype Cycle by Alex Kantrowitz (BuzzFeed)
- Skepticism About Biotechnology Isn’t Anti-Science by Tess Doezema (Slate)
- Uber Really Seriously Promises Flying Cars by 2020 by Alex Davies (Wired)
- Is Time Travel Possible, According To Science? by Ethan Siegel (Forbes)
- Better Call Saul S03E03: Sunk Costs by Sarah Parro (Arc)
- Fyre Festival, a Luxury Music Weekend, Crumbles in the Bahamas by Joe Coscarelli and Melena Ryzik (The New York Times)
- Kendrick Lamar is Hip-Hop’s King — But for How Long? by Paul Cantor (Medium)
- Video Games Are Better Without Stories by Ian Bogost (The Atlantic)
- The Writers Guild of America has Voted to Authorize a Strike, with 96 Percent in Favor by Alissa Wilkinson and Todd VanDerWerff (Vox)
- The Gospel of St. Paul & The Broken Bones by Caleb Farmer (Arc)
- Services like Netflix and Amazon Prime Video are Growing Much Faster than Traditional TV — Here’s How Much by Nathan McAlone (Business Insider)
- The Real Story Behind ESPN’s Wednesday Massacre by Sean Davis (The Federalist)
- Breaking Down All 32 Teams’ Draft Classes (ESPN)
- The Bears, Chiefs, and Texans All Bet Their Futures on QBs by Robert Mays (The Ringer)
- Steve Kerr’s Career Could be Threatened by Medical Condition by Scott Ostler (San Francisco Chronicle)
- What Happens When Soccer Bans Heading? by Noah Davis (The Ringer)
- Ray Hudson Just Had Himself a Messigasm by Brandon Anderson (Medium)
- Lavar Ball’s Lofty Ambitions Cost Son Lonzo Sneaker Deals with Nike, Adidas, and Under Armour by Kristian Winfield (SB Nation)
- 25 Most Heroic Losses in NBA Playoff History by Ryan Davis (CheatSheet)
This Week In History
April 29
1954 — Jerry Seinfeld, comedian and star of one of the most successful TV shows ever, is born.
1980 — Alfred Hitchcock (b. 1899), legendary filmmaker and master of suspense, passes away.
April 30
1789 — George Washington, for many the greatest American who ever lived, is inaugurated as the first President of the United States of America.
1883 — Edouard Manet (b. 1832), celebrated French painter, passes away. Read about him and see some of his best work here.
1945 — Adolf Hitler (b. 1889), one of the worst humans to ever live, kills himself before he can be captured.
May 1
1931 — The Empire State Building opens in New York City.
May 2
1519 — Leonardo da Vinci (b. 1452), one of the most brilliant all-around intellects and artistic geniuses the Western world has ever known, passes away.
2011 — Osama bin Laden (b. 1957), the architect behind the 9/11 attacks, who, like Hitler, is one of the worst humans to ever live, is killed by U.S. special forces.
May 4
1929 — Audrey Hepburn, an on-screen icon during the Golden Age of film, is born.
1979 — Margaret Thatcher, the Iron Lady, becomes the first woman to be elected Prime Minister of the United Kingdom.
Quote
Alfred Hitchcock:
Drama is life with the dull bits cut out.