Jenkins vs Bamboo — Which CI/CD tool to choose?
Jenkins and Bamboo are leading automation servers with plugins built for continuous integration. So before using them in your DevOps lifecycle, you must understand what exactly they are and how do they work. To understand the very same, read this article which talks about the usability face-off between Jenkins vs Bamboo.
The topics covered in this article are as follows:
- What is Jenkins?
- What is Bamboo?
- Differences between Jenkins and Bamboo
- Popularity
- License Terms
- Origin
- Ease of Setup
- User-friendly
- Documentation
- Platform Dependency
- Support
- Plugins Support
- Compatibility
- Which CI/CD tool you should choose?
Before, we look into the differences between Jenkins and Bamboo, let us understand the basics of Jenkins and Bamboo.
What is Jenkins?
Jenkins is one of the most popular tools in today’s market, built for Continuous Integration purposes. Written in Java, Jenkins is used to build and test software projects and makes it easy for developers to integrate the required changes to the project. This tool also aims to continuously deliver software by integrating a large number of testing and deployment software.
By using Jenkins, startups to hyper-growth companies can accelerate the software development process through automation. Also, Jenkins integrates the development life-cycle process of different kinds such as build, document, test, package, stage, deploy, static analysis and much more. It provides various plugins to allow integration of various DevOps stages. For example, if you want to use a particular tool, then you just need to install the required plugins for that particular tool.
Refer the image below to understand the role of Jenkins in various DevOps stages:
Next, in this article on Jenkins vs Bamboo let us understand the basics of Bamboo.
What is Bamboo?
Bamboo is an automation server used for Continuous Integration. Developed by Atlassian in 2007, this tool allows the developers to automatically build, document, integrate, test the source code and prepare an app for deployment. It comes with the flexibility to use various tools, easy to use graphical user interface and allows the developers to use CI/ CD methodologies.
With Bamboo, you can ensure high quality and status, get end-to-end visibility into release implementation and spend maximum time writing the code rather than integrate various software. It also provides built-in deployment support, powerful build agent management, automated merging, and built-in Git branch workflows.
In Bamboo, we have to create Plans, then set Stages, Jobs, and Tasks using the GUI. Refer below.
The differences between Jenkins vs Bamboo are briefly summarized in the below table. A detailed explanation is provided later in the article.
Jenkins vs Bamboo
In this face-off on Jenkins vs Bamboo, I will be comparing both these tools based on the following grounds:
- Popularity
- License Terms
- Origin
- Ease of Setup
- User-friendly
- Documentation
- Platform Dependency
- Support
- Plugins Support
- Compatibility
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Popularity
On comparing these tools based on popularity, Jenkins definitely wins the game and is much popular than Bamboo. Jenkins was released much before than Bamboo, and it immediately started gaining popularity among organizations.
Also, if you look at the current Google Trends of these tools, you will clearly observe that Jenkins is much ahead in the competition. Jenkins continues to dominate a solution to build a continuous delivery pipeline as it has more than 165,000 active installations.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: License Terms
Jenkins is an open-source tool, whereas Bamboo is a commercial/ licensed tool. Jenkins has a global community for development, but Bamboo has its own team of dedicated development. So, any individual or professionals working in the DevOps field can go and download Jenkins.
However, to use Bamboo you can download the free version available for 30 Days. After that, you have to buy the license either for $10 which provides 10 jobs, unlimited local agents, no remote agents or for $1270 which provides unlimited jobs and local agents. Here, remember that the more plan you have, the more will be the agents you will require. Else, you will risk creating a process and slowing down the process.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Origin
Well, the origin of both tools is the programming language — Java. Jenkins was developed as the Hudson project in 2004 by Kohsuke Kawaguchi and was first released in java.net in 2005.
Similarly, while developing Bamboo, Atlassian decided to use a simple Java-based plan description language, to ensure syntax checks, code auto-completion, validate code, and also run offline tests. In Bamboo, you can write your code in any JVM language which incorporated Java-like Groovy, Scala, or Kotlin. Do not have to worry, if you are not familiar with Java, both these tools will bootstrap you directly into a working environment with the help of the documentation available.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Ease of Setup
Both of these tools are quite easy to be installed and configured. They can be configured with a snap of your fingers. Yet, if we still have to choose one out of them, then I would say, Jenkins, stands out, as it can be done in 3 steps if Java and Apache Tomcat are already installed. You have to download the Jenkins war file from the official website, deploy the war file, and then install the required/ suggested plugins.
However, to setup Bamboo, you need to few more steps when compared to that of Jenkins. Here, after installing Java and create a dedicated user to run Bamboo, you have to follow the below steps:
- Download Bamboo
- Create an installation directory
- Create the home directory
- Start Bamboo
- Configure Bamboo
Jenkins vs Bamboo: User-friendly
When it comes to user-friendliness then Jenkins is not a confident defender here. This is because Bamboo has a much user-friendly approach with a neat and intuitive user interface. So, every time a new task is added, it provides proper guidance throughout the plan’s build and deployment states.
But, when it comes to Jenkins, this tool is completely based on functionality. So, in case you wish to make the Jenkins platform more intuitive, then you need to work extra on it. Yet, I would say these leaves a room for the developers to customize, create, allows the developers to choose from a variety of plugins.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Documentation
Jenkins and Bamboo both of them have fantastic online documentation that offers clients the option to research and find a solution before reaching the support for help.
In this documentation, you will find all the information related to the tools like, how to install, pre-requisites, steps to perform a task, commands, etc. Documentation also provides various tutorials to help you gain hands-on experience in the tool better.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Platform Dependency
Jenkins and Bamboo work on various platforms and can be integrated with various tools. The following are the different operating systems and browsers Jenkins and Bamboo can work on.
Jenkins:
- Works on operating systems such as Windows, Ubuntu, RedHat, MacOS.
- It can be used on browsers such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, and Internet Explorer.
Bamboo:
- Works on operating systems such as Windows, Linux, Solaris
- It can be used on browsers such as Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, Safari, and Edge.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Support
Jenkins offers global community support to users who are facing issues while using Jenkins. But Bamboo offers great professional support for licensed customers. It also has detailed online documentation available.
Apart from this, Bamboo gets support from the Atlassian community. So my take on this point is, that both of them do offer support. Yet, I would say its completely user-perspective regarding the help offered by these tools.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Plugins Support
Jenkins dominates this field and offers more than 1000 plugins which enable Jenkins to integrate with any tool like Git, Maven 2 project, Amazon EC2, HTML publisher. These plugins enable the user to give the best of solutions throughout the continuous delivery process. Even if a plugin does not exist, you can code it and share it with the community.
But, Bamboo is not the confident defender here. Bamboo has around 100 plugins in the Atlassian environment, as most of the features are built in the Bamboo marketplace. Also, this tool easily integrates with JIRA and Bitbucket when compared to that of Jenkins.
Jenkins vs Bamboo: Compatibility
Refer below for the comparison of these tools based on compatibility:
Since you are familiar with the nitty-gritty of Jenkins and Bamboo, in the next section, I will deal with the major question revolving in your mind.
Which CI/CD tool you should choose?
As I have already mentioned, both tools are prominent in the DevOps field and hold paramount importance. So, you can opt for either of the two. But before you choose your tool, there are a few important aspects that you need to consider like:
- Support and management offered by tools
- User interface and integration support
- Type of systems such as standalone systems and large software systems
In short, I would say it is your choice which tool you want to choose based on your requirement in the DevOps lifecycle. So, these are the relevant parameters you have to keep in mind before choosing one between, Jenkins vs Bamboo. I hope you found this article informative.
If you wish to check out more articles on the market’s most trending technologies like Artificial Intelligence, Python, Ethical Hacking, then you can refer to Edureka’s official site.
Do look out for other articles in this series which will explain the various other aspects of DevOps.
2. Git Tutorial
9. How To Orchestrate DevOps Tools?
13. Continuous Delivery vs Continuous Deployment
14. CI CD Pipeline
15. Docker Compose
16. Docker Swarm
18. Ansible Vault
19. Ansible Roles
20. Ansible for AWS
21. Jenkins Pipeline
23. Git vs GitHub
24. Top Git Commands
25. DevOps Interview Questions
28. Git Reflog
30. Top DevOps Skills That Organizations Are Looking For
33. Ansible Interview Questions And Answers
34. 50 Docker Interview Questions
36. Jenkins Interview Questions
39. Linux commands Used In DevOps
40. Maven For Building Java Applications
42. Nagios Interview Questions
Originally published at https://www.edureka.co on November 14, 2019.
