Photo By: Anthony Bevilacqua

Elevate, Don’t Exaggerate

How the Minutest Mistake Turned a Perfect Headline Into a Clickbaity One

Navigating the Fine Line: Clickbait vs. Compelling Headlines

Nimish Jalan
Inside The Mind Of A Writer
2 min readOct 19, 2023

--

“On the average, five times as many people read the headline as read the body copy. When you have written your headline, you have spent eighty cents out of your dollar.” — David Ogilvy

“Make it simple. Make it memorable. Make it inviting to look at. Make it fun to read.” — Leo Burnett

“Your headline has only one job — to stop your prospect and compel him to read the second sentence of your ad.” — Joseph Sugarman

I know, I’ve started the article with not one, but three quotes. I want to signify the importance of the headline.

Rather than writing a few 100 words, I wanted to seek help from the greatest minds to explain the importance of a headline.

They do a much better job than I can ever do.

Earlier this week, I wrote this article👇🏾

Screenshot from Author’s Online Library

Take a look at the headline and tell me what you think is wrong. What’s the mistake I made?

Before I begin, let me tell you the state of mind I was in.

8 months into daily writing practice, my articles on Medium saw a sudden outburst of comments and claps.

My articles were getting distributed to a much larger audience than I was used to.

I woke up feeling like a kid with a key to the toy store.

In my excitement, I ended up writing information that seemed exaggerated.

The number 11,578% while true, comes across as clickbaity.

In less than a week, I find myself cringing at the headline because as a reader I’ve been burnt way too many times with such headlines.

I should have written something a lot more believable.

In my excitement, thanks to the minutest mistake, I managed to ruin a perfectly well-written article.

A lesson well learnt.

Here’s my 7-step blueprint to write better headlines for those who want to dive deeper.

Like me, if you too are on a journey to enhance your writing and reach a larger audience, pay disproportionate attention to your headlines.

What do you think of this analysis? I’d love to hear some opposing views because that’s what helps me grow the most.

--

--

Nimish Jalan
Inside The Mind Of A Writer

Prioritizing writing, experiments, failure and growth. Committed to write 365 days straight! Come say hi :)