In an era where dating apps have become the norm, finding a lasting connection seems more daunting than ever. Amidst a sea of swipes and superficial interactions, the principles of behavioral science offer context and actionable tips on how to make modern dating work for you.
Behavioral science and dating
The Paradox of Choice in online dating
The Paradox of Choice, a pivotal concept in behavioural science, illuminates the psychological dilemma that emerges when individuals are confronted with an excess of options. Rooted in the research by Barry Schwartz, this paradox reveals a counterintuitive aspect of human decision-making: an abundance of choices, rather than liberating us, can lead to decision paralysis, increased anxiety, and a pervasive sense of dissatisfaction with our final selections.
In the digital realm of dating apps, where users are bombarded with an endless carousel of potential partners, the manifestations of this paradox are particularly visible. Users find themselves trapped in a continuous search for the ideal match, plagued by the nagging suspicion that a better option is just a swipe away. This relentless pursuit of perfection, spurred by the illusion of boundless choice, often culminates in a cycle of transient interactions that lack depth and meaning, and that don’t lead to fulfilling nor lasting relationships.
Decision fatigue
Decision fatigue, a concept explored within the broader context of cognitive psychology, refers to the deteriorating quality of decisions made by an individual after a long session of decision-making. This phenomenon is especially relevant in the context of online dating, where users are often required to make a high volume of rapid decisions on potential matches.
The relentless nature of swiping through profiles can lead to a diminished capacity to make thoughtful choices, ultimately affecting the quality of connections formed. Research in decision-making and cognitive load theory suggests that an overload of choices taxes the brain’s executive functions, leading to shortcuts that prioritise immediate gratification over long-term value — a pattern all too common in the swipe-centric dating landscape. To mitigate this issue, it is advisable to limit the frequency of swiping and focus on interacting with a select few matches rather than going on long swiping sessions.
Confirmation bias & idealisation in swiping-based dating
Confirmation bias describes the tendency of individuals to seek, interpret, favour, and recall information in a way that confirms their preexisting beliefs or hypotheses. In the realm of online dating, this bias can significantly impact users’ perceptions and interactions, leading them to overlook potential matches that could be compatible while focusing on those who superficially affirm their expectations. This phenomenon is amplified by the algorithms of dating apps, which often prioritise profiles based on previous interactions and expressed preferences, creating a feedback loop that reinforces narrow criteria and superficial traits.
To combat confirmation bias and encourage more open, genuine connections, experts suggest broadening search criteria to include profiles outside usual preferences and engaging in reflective pauses to critically assess why certain profiles are appealing. Awareness training about cognitive biases and their impact on decision-making can also help users approach online dating with a more open and discerning mindset. By challenging preconceived notions and expanding the scope of potential matches, users can enhance their chances of finding meaningful relationships, moving beyond superficial preferences to deeper compatibility.
The importance of self-reflection
Logan Ury, a behavioural scientist turned dating coach, emphasises the importance of self-reflection in the search for a partner, advocating for a deep understanding of one’s dating patterns, preferences, and biases to make better relationship choices. Exercises like the 8 post-date questions encourage people to document their thoughts and experiences after a date, helping identify recurring patterns, and giving insights on who they should continue to see and who they should let go. By engaging in self-reflection, individuals can align their dating strategies with their core values and goals, leading to more meaningful relationships, moving away from superficial traits
Trends around dating apps
The landscape of online dating, once dominated by the convenience and novelty of swipe-based apps, is undergoing a significant transformation as users increasingly voice their dissatisfaction with the superficial nature of these platforms. Studies indicate that up to 62% of users feel like dating apps prioritise physical appearance over meaningful connections, leading to a pervasive sense of superficiality and dissatisfaction. This frustration is exacerbated by gender imbalances, with men significantly outnumbering women on most dating apps (on Tinder, it’s 75% men vs 25% women). The consequence is a growing disillusionment with the efficiency of swipe-based models and a yearning for more meaningful interactions.
In response to these challenges, there’s a noticeable shift towards dating solutions that foster deeper, more authentic connections. Users are expressing a strong preference for platforms that offer detailed profiles and compatibility-based matching, with 75% indicating a desire for features that enable a deeper understanding of potential matches. This pivot away from the swipe-centric approach towards platforms that prioritise genuine connections reflects a broader cultural shift in the digital dating landscape.
Success rates of different dating approaches
While in the 80s the majority of people met via common friends or at work, the vast majority of people are now focussed on online dating as their main strategy to find a partner. While dating apps have surged in popularity, their effectiveness is increasingly scrutinised. A striking 45% of users report feelings of frustration and losing hope, a sentiment exacerbated by challenges such as gender imbalances and the superficial interactions these platforms often foster. Furthermore, reports indicate a concerning number of users fail to receive matches at all, highlighting a gap between the promise of these platforms and the user experience.
In contrast, more traditional and personalised methods of meeting partners, such as through matchmakers and interest-based activities, are gaining renewed attention for their effectiveness.
Matchmaking services, which offer a curated approach to dating by personally connecting individuals based on compatibility and deeper criteria, stand out for their success — 70% to 85% of users end up forming long-term relationships or marriages. Unlike the often hit-or-miss nature of dating apps, matchmakers provide a service grounded in understanding individual preferences and relationship goals, leading to more meaningful connections.
Similarly, joining clubs, groups, or activities that align with personal interests not only fosters a sense of community but also increases the chances of meeting someone with shared values and passions. Moreover, research has found that couples who engage in shared activities report higher levels of relationship satisfaction and longevity, which is aligned with the value of meeting someone over shared passions.
These personalised approaches contrast sharply with the impersonal swipe mechanics of dating apps. The emphasis on quality over quantity, and the focus on deep compatibility rather than superficial attraction, marks a shift back towards more intentional forms of connection. While dating apps offer the allure of convenience and breadth, the depth and intentionality facilitated by matchmakers and shared activities resonate with those seeking lasting relationships. This trend underscores a broader desire for authenticity and meaningful engagement in the digital age, highlighting the enduring value of personal connections in forming romantic relationships.
Get matched by Oscar
Oscar is pioneering a shift away from the superficial swipes to rediscover the magic of authentic connections, leveraging matchmaking principles.
Our method is simple yet transformative: through a detailed questionnaire, we delve into your personality, preferences, and what you find attractive. This insight allows us to find you a compatible match. Once we’ve found you a match, you will receive their bio, and if mutual interest sparks, we arrange a blind date at a cozy bar. This means no swiping, no endless texting — just the opportunity to explore real chemistry face-to-face.
Oscar is here to transform how you find love, focusing on the magic of real-life encounters and meaningful connections. Sign up today →
