A Black Friday Mishap: Resolving a Double Charge with Sarah
Black Friday is always a whirlwind. The buzz of great deals, the rush to check out before items go out of stock, and the thrill of scoring that must-have product make it an exciting day for shoppers and retailers alike. But with so much activity, occasional hiccups are bound to happen.
With her student budget already stretched thin, Sarah had planned every penny of her Black Friday purchases to ensure she got the essentials and a few well-deserved treats. But when an accidental double charge threatened to derail her careful planning, it’s up to you as our customer service representative to make it right.
Section Summary
This interactive article introduces a real-world customer service challenge involving Sarah, a university student who was accidentally charged twice for a Black Friday laptop purchase. With a tight budget and urgent financial concerns, Sarah anxiously reaches out to customer service for help. You will step into the role of a customer service representative, working to resolve her issue promptly and professionally. This scenario will help you practice empathy, clear communication, and effective problem-solving in customer interactions.
The Incident
Sarah is a second-year engineering student juggling classes, part-time work, and mounting tuition costs. Black Friday was her chance to finally upgrade her outdated laptop for one with enough processing power to handle her design software. She had found a fantastic deal on our site: a high-performance laptop, originally $999, discounted to $649.
Excited about the deal and nervous about it selling out, Sarah quickly placed her order. Everything seemed fine until she checked her bank account later that day. To her dismay, she noticed two identical charges of $649 — money she didn’t have to spare.
She needs to resolve the issue quickly to avoid falling short on rent and groceries this month. Sarah immediately contacted our customer service team through email and followed up the next morning anxiously via live chat. Due to the Black Friday rush, there has been a 48 hour delay for her email to reach any of our agents. Sarah is now in a state of panic, and has spent most of the last two days anxiously checking for a response from our team.
Sarah’s Email to Customer Service
Subject: URGENT: Double Charge on Black Friday Order
Hi,
I placed an order for a laptop during your Black Friday sale yesterday, and I just noticed that I’ve been charged twice for the same order. I only ordered one laptop, but my bank account shows two identical charges of $649.
I’m a university student on a tight budget, and this double charge is causing me a lot of stress because I need that money for rent and groceries. Please help me resolve this as soon as possible.
Thank you,
Sarah
Practice Exercises
Section Summary:
The practice exercises will guide you through a structured approach to handling customer concerns. You will start with a PAIBOC analysis to break down Sarah’s situation, identifying key details and objectives. Then, you will draft a response that acknowledges the issue, reassures the customer, and provides a clear resolution. Afterward, you will evaluate your email, ensuring it is empathetic, professional, and solution-oriented. Finally, the AI integration exercise will help you refine your work by using AI as a brainstorming and feedback tool while maintaining human judgment and authenticity in your responses.
Activity 1: Analyze the Situation
Before drafting your response to Sarah, perform a PAIBOC Analysis. Be sure to write out the full analysis so that you can refer to in the following activities.
As you complete this step, keep in mind that the insights gained here will guide your email drafting in Activity 2. For example, identifying Sarah’s emotional state (frustration, anxiety) in this analysis will help shape a more empathetic response.
If you feel lost, try asking yourself questions such as:
What is the desired outcome? Think about why you are writing this email. What are you trying to accomplish as a customer service agent? What is the best possible outcome that you could achieve?
What do you know? Summarize Sarah’s situation. What are the key details about her, her purchase, and the impact of this issue? How do you think she feels right now? How has this situation impacted her?
What should you do? Identify reasonable steps you could take to address Sarah’s concerns. Are there compensation options, such as a goodwill gesture, that could help improve her experience? Are there any immediate fixes, or will the solution take time? What sort of compensation would you want if you were Sarah? How do you want Sarah to feel after reading your email? How can you convey empathy and professionalism?
Activity 2: Draft a Response
Using your analysis from Activity 1, write an email to Sarah. Your email should:
- Acknowledge the issue and empathize with Sarah’s situation.
- Clearly explain the steps you’re taking to resolve the problem.
- Provide a timeline for the resolution and set clear expectations.
- Offer reassurance and, if applicable, a goodwill gesture to improve her experience.
💡 Example: Empathetic vs. Generic Response
Get May Hall’s stories in your inbox
Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.
Below is a comparison between a generic and an empathetic response. Notice how small changes in tone and detail can significantly impact the customer experience.
Generic:
Dear Customer,
Thank you for your email. We see that you were charged twice. We will process your refund within the next 5–7 business days.
Let us know if you have any further questions.
Empathetic:
Hello Sarah,
I’m sorry to hear about this double charge. I completely understand how stressful this must be, especially during the holiday season. I’ve already initiated the refund, and you can expect the amount to be credited back to your account within 5–7 business days.
To make up for the inconvenience, we’re offering you a free extended warranty on your new laptop and a $25 gift card to use toward a laptop accessory of your choice.
Please don’t hesitate to reach out if you have any further concerns — we’re here to ensure this is resolved smoothly for you.
Activity 3: Evaluate Your Email
Review your email and assess its quality by answering the following:
- Did you address Sarah’s concerns clearly and professionally?
- Were you empathetic in your response?
- Did you offer a concrete solution and set appropriate expectations?
- Is your email easy to read and understand, with no errors or unnecessary information?
Revise your email if necessary to ensure it meets these criteria. Remember, clarity and empathy go a long way in customer service.
Activity 4: Leveraging AI as a Dynamic Assistant
Now, let’s bring AI into the exercise. Use an AI tool as a dynamic assistant to enhance your work. Here’s how:
Brainstorming Support: If you’re unsure about how to phrase something or need ideas for structuring your email, ask the AI for suggestions. For example:
“Can you suggest a polite way to apologize to a customer for a billing mistake?”
“How can I explain the refund process in simple terms?”
Feedback on Your Email: Share your draft with the AI and ask it for constructive feedback:
“Does this email sound empathetic and professional?”
“Is my explanation of the timeline clear?”
Checking Grammar and Clarity: Use the AI to proofread your email for grammar, spelling, and clarity.
Important Note About Using AI
While AI can be a helpful tool for brainstorming and improving your work, it’s important to remember that large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT don’t “understand” content the way humans do. They’re great at mimicking language patterns but lack true comprehension, emotions, or experience.
As you use AI, focus on leveraging it as a collaborative tool. Your personal judgment, empathy, and understanding of the context are critical to crafting an authentic, effective response.
Remember to critically evaluate AI-generated suggestions to maintain authenticity and appropriateness.
Note: The current version of Chat GPT at the time of this article is the GPT-4-turbo model (also referred to as GPT-4.5). All tips and advice for AI use is based on this model.
Reflection
Customer service skills such as clear communication, empathy, and problem-solving are valuable in many areas beyond support roles. Think about a time when you had to resolve a misunderstanding, respond to a concern, or assist someone in a challenging situation.
- How did you approach the conversation?
- What strategies worked well, and what could have been improved?
- How might the techniques from this exercise help you handle similar situations in the future?
Take a few minutes to reflect on these questions and consider how you can apply these skills in your own personal or professional interactions.
