Top Stories published by vBriefly in August of 2012
01
02
04
05
07
08
09
10
11
12
14
22
24
25
27
28
29
30

The Myth of Debate Truthiness by Jake Nebel

In “Tycoons of Piety,” Rebar Niemi warns against blurring the line between debate and the real world. I would warn against just the opposite: pretending there is such a line. 
He writes:


Against Tabula Rasa, Part 2: Arguments and Assumptions

In my last post, I argued that judge must take rules of inference for granted. In this post, I argue that judges also have to do what many consider to be intervention.
Most of us think dropped claims don’t matter (e.g., the aff can’t…


Against Tabula Rasa, Part 3: Degrees of Belief

In my first post, I argued that the judge is constrained not by possibility, but by rationality. In my second post, I argued that the judge’s starting points for a debate bear on in-round disputes because of conflicting assumptions. My next…

These were the top 14 stories published by vBriefly in August of 2012. You can also dive into daily archives for August of 2012 by using the calendar at the top of this page.

About
vBriefly
News, resources, and advice for high school debate.
More information
Editors